FAI wins battle for Gibson

http://www.rte.ie/sport/soccer/2007/1022/gibsond.html

FAI wins battle for Gibson
Monday, 22 October 2007 18:54

It seems Darren Gibson has been cleared to play for the Republic of Ireland.

An FAI delegation met with FIFA in Zurich today to discuss Gibson’s future.

The IFA insist that the Derry-born midfielder should not be representing the Republic because he was born in Northern Ireland.

The word from today’s meeting is that FIFA will not act retrospectively on such cases, and they will be making an official announcement later in the week.

I think everyone can breath a little bit easier now tonight. :grin:

Did anyone see the rumours doing the rounds today (primarily on foot.ie) that Shane Long’s been playing illegally in the last batch of qualifiers having been sent off in either an U-21 or U-20 game last year and picking up a 5 game ban?

Talk of point deduction and / or fines.

It seems as though it’s ok because he didn’t come on during the Slovakia away game. Typical of the FAI to mess up their administration though. Pack of fools.

Long fiasco could have cost qualifying points
By Philip Quinn
Tuesday October 23 2007

Embattled FAI chief executive John Delaney is under-fire over the Shane Long eligibility fiasco, which will cost the FAI a fine but could have cost the Irish team an away point in the European Championship 2008 qualifiers.

Long was an unused substitute against Slovakia last month but he shouldn’t have been on the bench as he was serving a five-game UEFA ban for a red card in an Irish U19 international in 2006.

Under UEFA rules, suspensions carry through different grades so when Long moved up to U21 level, the ban came too.

And that’s where things became complicated.

European football’s governing body will allow a suspended player take part in senior internationals, once they don’t run in tandem with U21 games.

Long, therefore, was able to participate against Germany last Saturday week at Croke Park as there was no competitive U21 game the night before.

But Long wasn’t eligible to play against either Slovakia, which the FAI didn’t realise, or against Cyprus, which the FAI twigged just it in time, making up a fictitious injury story and sending him home.

Had Long played even one minute in Bratislava, a 2-2 draw would have become a 3-0 defeat.

The FAI issued a statement last night, attempting to shift the blame at UEFA’s door.

It read: "When Shane Long was called into the senior squad for the Euro 2008 qualifier versus San Marino last February the FAI checked his eligibility with UEFA and was assured that he was free to play at senior international level and that his suspension only applied to under age level.

“Once the association became aware, after the game in Slovakia, that there was a problem with the player’s eligibility for senior internationals, it immediately contacted UEFA for clarification,” continued the FAI statement.

"On reflection, UEFA has confirmed that they recognise how the FAI came to the conclusion they did because of the content of the correspondence received from UEFA

That Gibson case is quiet significant. It will be interesting to see FIFA’s announcement later in the week. The FAI and IFA should really get together and sort out an All Irish team. Anybody know of any other sports which are partioned? Soccer is the only one I can think off the top of my head.

Not sure there’ll be much to the announcement - seems as though the broad case is lost. Strange that a guy born in Derry can choose an Irish passport, call himself Irish and be Irish to all intents and purposes but not be allowed to play soccer for us. And compare that to the likes of Paul Butler who was capped for Ireland just because he married an Irish woman.

So is the rule that all Irish players can choose which part of Ireland they want to play for? I thought the rule used to be that all Irish players could play for the 26 if they had a grandparent born before partition. Given that fewer players now have grandpartents born before 1922 I was under the impression that players would now no longer be able to choose their ‘country’. Common sense it seems may have prevailed.

That used to be the rule I think but since the signing of the Good Friday Agreement citizens of the six counties are entitled by law to choose either Irish or British nationality based on their preference. So they’re all entitled to Irish passports, they just don’t meet FIFA’s criteria for Irishness.