Keane's Latest Rant II

Of all the players to criticise this is plain ridiculous.


Keane questions Given approach
Tuesday, 27 March 2007 10:04
Roy Keane believes Republic of Ireland captain Shay Given has played too many games for his country.

The Newcastle United goalkeeper will tomorrow night equal Pat Bonner’s 80-cap record for Ireland, in the Euro 2008 qualifying match at Croke Park.

But Sunderland manager Keane claims other goalkeepers should have started friendly internationals, claiming Given has picked up caps to get ‘a pat on the back’.

Keane said: 'I think players have agendas - certain players come over all the time no matter what.

'Maybe they want to get 50 or 100 caps and a pat on the back for it.

‘I think Shay’s one of those ones - he wants to get 200 caps.’

Given, 30, had a spell on loan at Sunderland 11 years ago, before joining their north-east rivals for 1.5million from Blackburn the following year.

And Keane continued in The Sun: 'Shay seems to have played every game - even friendlies.

'You have other keepers, who travel all the time. Then, when they do play, they’re taken off.

'I’ve always thought, when it comes to the lads who travel all the time, “give them a game”.

‘Qualifiers you have to win - but with friendly matches, give the lads who travel a game and don’t be changing them at half-time, give them a full game.’

Prior to Saturday’s 1-0 Euro 2008 qualfying defeat of Wales in Dublin, Keane accused those in the current Republic line-up of under-performing and also claimed there was a bias against Cork-based players.

It’s not really Givens fault if he’s picked for every game. If he gets called up, as he always will be, he’ll be picked. Given isnt giving himself ‘a pat on the back’ its being given(excuse the pun)

What an irrational argument (it could have been farmer speaking it was so off the wall). Criticising Given for being proud to represent his country - what an idiot.

If he accused Given of a lack of ambition for signing a 4 year deal at Newcastle last year then fair enough (that’s what I presumed he had done when I read the headline on the RTE site) but to have a go at someone for showing loyalty is ridiculous.

I really think Keanes rant is misguided, then again he obviously knows Givens character a lot better than anyone on here. I think he should be directing his tirade against the management. Given has no say in whether or not another goalkeeper gets 90 mins or not. Keane is right in that other players deserve a crack at a full game when the game in question is a friendly.

I dont know Raven, it is madman Keane we’re talking about here. The bitterness is probably a factor allright.

I thought Dunne’s comments the other week about Kerr were idiotic. Kilbane has always given full effort for his country and attitude has always been first class. I remember Keane saying he wasn’t sure if he wanted Keane back after Saipan so I think Keane still has a bit of a grudge. Silly thing for jim to say nevertheless.