O\'Driscoll suspected fractured cheekbone

First match report from someone who was there.

Not sure if you could say it was pre-planned to try and take him out but at the least Dourthe’s comments seem to show how the Bayonne team would have been fired up in the dressing-room.

O’Driscoll taken to hospital
Gerry Thornley In Bayonne

RUGBY World Cup warm-up/Bayonne 6 Ireland 42: Though the fear always lurked that this hastily arranged fixture might become a battleground with Bayonne hosting one of France’s World Cup pool opponents, a game that might become known as the Battle of Bayonne was not what Ireland wanted.
Ultimately, the abiding memory of the night will be the sight of the Ireland captain Brian O’Driscoll being led to an ambulance by his cousin, the team doctor Gary O’Driscoll, to be taken to hospital for an X-ray on a suspected fractured cheekbone.

“Of course I’m worried,” admitted coach Eddie O’Sullivan. “If the doctor thinks it’s more than a wound and that it needs an X-ray that is a concern.”

O’Driscoll collapsed clutching his face after one of the many off-the-ball incidents in an ill-tempered game when seemingly punched by Bayonne’s New Zealand-born second-half replacement Makeera Tewhata.

The prognosis on the other casualties, Denis Leamy (bang on a shoulder) and Paddy Wallace (bang on the head) was at least better.

Not quite the romp then that Ireland were expecting, indeed far from it on a balmy but ultimately wet night in the Stade Jean Dauger.

Ireland threatened to carve Bayonne apart at the outset of each half before becoming embroiled in a tetchy affair that exposed their predictable ring-rust.

“It was a worthwhile exercise,” maintained O’Sullivan in admitting mistakes abounded in “a typical first run-out of the season”.

He added, “We never expected it to be a garden party and I don’t mind physicality, but I do mind cheap shots. I’m fine except for that one incident. He (O’Driscoll) may be fine tomorrow but we’ll wait and see.”

As a flavour of what to expect come the Coupe du Monde in just over three weeks’ time it will have been a useful exercise, but there is clearly a vast amount of work to do in fine-tuning the Irish squad.

Most of all, they’ll hope to be much more clinical when in the red zone, because here they too often let Bayonne off the hook.

The night wasn’t without its other worries, in particular the injury to Leamy, who had been one of Ireland’s more impressive players - getting mitts on the ball, looking fired up and hunting out the physical exchanges - before his night’s work was cut short.

Ronan O’Gara tapped over a first-minute penalty before Paul O’Connell rumbled over for the first of his two tries after Gordon D’Arcy had sped through a gap in the Bayonne defence off static ball to find Girvan Dempsey.

A virtuoso try from Denis Hickie from 75 metres out when collecting a clever crosskick from O’Gara made it 15-9 inside 10 minutes, but then mistakes proliferated as a fired-up Bayonne came into it.

Richard Dourthe, who, true to type, had become agitated from early on, put his team on the scoreboard with a penalty and a well-struck drop goal.

Dourthe’s last game for France was a nightmarish midfield dissection at the hands, or more pertinently the feet, of O’Driscoll. He was dropped, never to play for les Bleus again. Dourthe had suggested in an interview printed in L’quipe yesterday that if O’Driscoll were injured it would be doing France a favour in the World Cup. He also expressed his eagerness to make a few tackles on the Irish captain.
O’Driscoll took exception to one off-the-ball hit as Andrew Trimble skated in for a try on half-time after the centre had cut back inside.

In truth, Trimble was a little fortunate to score, having lost O’Driscoll’s support run and sought to attempt an improbable overhead pass as Xavier Garbajosa and Daniel Larrechea, two of five Bayonne debutants, collided in endeavouring to tackle and began their inquest as Trimble touched down.

The score, and ensuing 20-6 interval scoreline, was a relief after an undistinguished second quarter.

Scarcely a minute after the resumption, Alan Quinlan punched through the Bayonne line for Hickie to skip deftly along the touchline and reach out for a classic winger’s try by the corner flag.

Better followed in perhaps the highlight of the night from an Irish perspective. A superb clear-out by Neil Best and pick-up by Simon Easterby ensured the continuity from which Marcus Horan showed typically deft hands to make the offload in the tackle that released O’Connell for an eye-catching 30 metre gallop to the line, fending off one of two would-be tacklers.

Soon though, the exchanges became tetchy again, Irish players reacting angrily to perceived wrongdoings, and the referee responded by brandishing yellow cards.

Larrechea was sinbinned for taking exception to a late charge by Easterby, and O’Driscoll required attention and was replaced by Geordan Murphy seemingly after taking a punch by Tewhata.

Right on cue, the rain fell as Ireland sought to restore order by opting for O’Gara to kick the penalty.

Another show of the ball to Horan on his outside and neat turn of foot saw Hickie complete his hat-trick but even as he did Horan was taking violent exception to a late hit.

The play had continued while a pole-axed Paddy Wallace was being treated, which resulted in Rob Linde’s sinbinning.

He fractured his sinus and will be out for 3-4 weeks. Looks like he’ll miss all the warm up games and the first qualifier. Could’ve been worse.

Yeah could have been much worse alright. He get targeted quite a bit these days which reflects his importance to Ireland. Fats made a good point on the other thread about the lack of sanctions/suspensions for this game because it was a friendly. It invited the messy stuff because guys felt they could have a clean go at someone and go unpunished.

The problem with the tight schedule is that it basically puts a big target on BO’D’s face for the whole RWC. If I was playing against him I be sure target a tackle/ruck at the poor guys face knowing that it will take him out of play.

In opposition you have to minimize their strengths and a knock on BO’D is fair game. Get him off the pitch.

There’s no doubt he will be targeted and the way he plays the game - while very laudable and very effective it puts him in the firing line all the time. But it might be an interesting test of his pain threshold. It’s not the type of injury that affects his mobility or ability to play. So if he gets a bang on the cheek it will likely be very sore but if he can tolerate the sharp pain then I think he’ll be able to play on.

Put it this way if this injury happened against France I’d expect him to be on the bench against Argentina, come on if needed and to play the rest of the tournament.

I’d love to think that it will put a poker up his ass in terms of aggression. Based on the Eng V France friendly last week, we’re going to need to throw everything we have at them to succeed in undoing the heartache of Feb 11th.

I was watching the NRL on Setanta Sports this morning and O’Driscoll got a shout-out from the Aussie commentators - Channel 9 I think they take their feed from.

There was a break in play and one of them just said “And greetings to the Irish rugby union team in Bayonne who suffered a blow last night when Brian O’Driscoll got a bang on the cheek and fractured a sinus. He’s a big player for them so hope he makes a quick recovery.” Bizarre mention but just shows how big a name O’Driscoll is globally.

Here’s the punch:

It’s the slow motion replay round about the minute mark where you can see it properly.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RLoExeByUiE

Tries are here:

Post edited by: therock67, at: 2007/08/19 23:05

link to the punch doesn’t work.

Sorry updated now

That is some punch.

Disappointing to see none of the pack go in and take their lad out in response.

Have to agree with you Bandage. O’Connell and O’Callaghan come running in and don’t really do anything. Uncharacteristically, D’Arcy seems the most wound up and O’Callaghan seems to be telling him to calm down. Quinlan offers a bit but O’Connell just busies himself with the lads on the ground, which looks fairly petered out at that stage.

In fairness to O’Callaghan, I read him saying afterwards that they were conscious the French lads could throw digs at them carefree but that if the Irish lads got in trouble for throwing a punch it could cost them their World Cup.

Re the actual punch, he’s not squared up to O’Driscoll because there’s a player in between them but Tewhata has clearly spotted O’Driscoll from the other side and kind of comes over the top of the bodies to catch him flush, so O’Driscoll can’t really see it coming. It doesn’t really look like he hit him from the side of behind though, which I thought Hickie seemed to be saying, but he still catches him unawares.

I think the forwards were clearly conscious of the world cup. 1 punch could easily see you out of the World Cup - especially if it did damage to the opponent. That’s why they were being peacemakers more than anything.

Re the punch itself there is no obvious confrontation between O’Driscoll and the second row. There’s a bit of grappling and your man spots O’Driscoll at jab range and catches him fairly plumb. Low blow because it’s not as though it was a proper free for all - it looked like it was just pushing and shoving.

strong rumour goin around that o’driscoll had an operation on a fractured cheekbone on saturday night in beaumont hospital.
apparently you cannot break your sinus without the cheekbone goin as well.

rumour comes from a doctor in beaumont so there you go.

Should that have kept him out of the World Cup if the rumour was true?

thepiedpiper wrote:

Should that have kept him out of the World Cup if the rumour was true?

No, I still think the doctor plans on watching the World Cup.

If that rumour is true, you’d have to imagine it’d keep him out until at least the quarters stage. When Steinmetz did it he was out for five or six weeks and then broke it again in his first match back. You’re just not going to be able to avoid getting bangs on the face playing rugby, nevermind people targetting you.

O’Sullivan does have previous in this department. A couple of Six Nations ago, he made out that O’Driscoll might come back from a hamstring strain when he didn’t get close in the end. It forces the opposition to spend time on their defence planning for him playing.

Another angle on the punch here. Very good quality video but is just a fraction late getting to the action.

If anything Tewhata and O’Driscoll do appear to be more square on to each other in this angle, but there’s no way O’Driscoll’s doing anything but breaking up the grappling. Ref is more guilty from this angle though. Don’t know how he didn’t see it because clearly everybody else does.

http://www.brightcove.com/title.jsp?title=1137833060

If that rumour is true get your bets on for what stage of the WC Dricco will play his first game

I think those videos watched together suggest that O’Connell and O’Callaghan were nowhere near the incident when it happened which explains further why they did nothing when they got there.

Betsen missed 3 months this season I think with a fractured cheekbone.

And as Fats has rightly said O’Sullivan has done this before with O’Driscoll. I still think it’s not true though. O’Sullivan likes a good complaint when he feels aggrieved (not a criticism of him) and I can’t see him underplaying the injury when there is an obvious culprit for him to have a real go at in public. Fecking hope it’s not true anyway.