No live stick hurling games on TV this weekend. No joy on the radio either. Fans of the game were left desperately scrambling around the wireless to see if any local radio stations were bothered to broadcast it as the main stations were broadcasting some rugby match instead last night.
GAA BeoSERIES 16, EPISODE 52
Live coverage of Kerry v Cork from Austin Stack Park, Tralee in the seventh round of the Allianz Football League and deferred coverage of Clare v Tipperary from Cusack Park, Ennis in the Quarter-Final of the Allianz Hurling League. Presented by Micheal Ă Domhnaill with commentary by Brian Tyers, AodĂĄn Mac Gearailt, CuĂĄn Ă Flatharta and Cathal Moore
I wouldnât mind getting a proper full time administrator into each county to be honest. And when I say proper, I dont mean the lads who are in there at present, lads who lucked into the roles. I mean a lad who understands putting structures into place and has a bit of dynamism about him and not beholden to factions or cliques.
Iâd also to happen across a genie in a magic lamp. I suspect the latter is more likely to happen.
I know itâs a different level but no one should be allowed near a pitch without basic training skills. Some of the carry on Iâve seen from lads coaching juveniles would scare ya.
Itâs vitally important to hammer out bad habits out of kids early on.
Totally agree. Underage coaching is absolutely terrible. Way worse than it was 5-6 years ago. So the more courses they do the worse the coaching. There is something in that. In their present guise i think most coaching courses are bullshit and they lack a real emphasis on Coaching education and you are coaching people, not machines or teams.
That report is great, and has to be welcomed, but the journalists approach to it is very biased and and totally disingenuous. He focus on Sports Science. Now there are some bluffers out there as was mention by Tomas OâSe recently (i think it may be one of these teams) about 2 weight sessions a day every 2nd day and 10km runs in between. But anyone in S&C who is genuinely qualified and wants to do their best will tell you its very often managers who will keep their distance and not involve you. Now he does mention it about the guy who said âi donât know anything about that sports science stuffâ, but thats purely ignorence, bad coaching, bad managing of team management (which he is responsible for) and a total lack of coaching education.
Its the coaches of these teams would for me be tge real issue there, bot the spirts science. Its up to the coach/manager to do his due dilligence. Now tge lad who was having guys in twice a day was clearly a bluffer and clearly taking them for a ride. But its still the managers fault.
This goes back to the irish attitude (which we share with other people on this Island and Australia but nowhere else) to coaching and not accepting it as a trade or a skill. There is still a feeling of it being âjust something you do after playingâ. Along with the fact that there is still huge belief in the fact that good players make good coaches. It doesnât preclude them from becoming good, but i am starting to believe more and more that it is actually a huge barrier for them and some psychological training would need to go with it.the first thing they have to realise is just because it came easy enough to tgem does not mean its the same for everyone.
Not sure how its damming to benefits of S&C? The benefits of anything are only beneficial when applied correctly. S&C should not suffer from managers makinh shit choices and not doing their jobs correctly. Or indeed County Boards picking bluffing managers
A lot of it is Down to clubs. Whoever shouts loudest or has highest opinion of themselves gets heard. Most lads are too busy with earning a living to care so the loud mouths and spoofers assume positions of control. Happens from underage up. I see fuckers in Crokes over underage teams with track jackets with their initials on them. Cunts.
The odd time you get lucky and the loud mouth does know what he is doing.
[quote=âcaoimhaoin, post:34, topic:13135, full:trueâ]In their present guise i think most coaching courses are bullshit and they lack a real emphasis on Coaching education and you are coaching people, not machines or teams.
[/quote]
quick one Kev and I know we had previous discussions before in a similar vein, but have you been on any coaching courses recently and if so what were they or arranged by who?
Ya, FMS course, last year. Iâm doing various study all tge time. I deliver workshops to coaches, some of them very âqualifiedâ with their Level 2 or a UEFA Licence etc, but completely blinkered or indeed not suited at all to coaching. But i know a number of coaches actually delivering courses around Ireland, particularly in GAA.
The courses donât give the participants the ability to fish, they buy them a fish.
There is no accountability thereafter so the course is a waste of time and only a box ticking exercise. Participants go away and do their own thing anyway.
I know alot of very good candidates turned off coaching by having to do extensive courses at all. They breed a certain type of person/coach.
Very blanket of course what i say above and tgere are exceptions. But its very personal or club driven. As in really good leaders within particular clubs. It many are turned off that unless they happen to be in a good financial/work position themselves. So its pure pot luck for clubs.
TUM is right, its the âpersonalitiesâ that get alot of these coaching jobs. Its an ego thing.
The IRFU are the only one doing it well. There is constant central contact, accountability and fenerally less assholes. I know many many people who are simply completely turned off the GAA in particular and to a lesser extent Soccer.
Soccer and GAA has failed in coaching. We have taken our lead from Englisg Rugby League and Soccer and look at the state of them.