Tom Humphries on the Grand Slam

Love the team and everything they did. Hate the fuckwittery of the ā€œlow liesā€ that went with. Also massively respect the commercial machine that milked it and used the money to fund the game elsewhere. But as you are well aware Iā€™m long on the record; home club first, Ireland second and Munster third.

Itā€™s just a pity that so many people were turned off by the bandwagon, albeit this place is a very skewed sample. The achievement of winning the HEC with 13 Irish players, 12 of them Munstermen, will stand up alongside the great achievements of Irish rugby

Dp

I donā€™t know man, I would equate it to the Wexford county team patting themselves on the back for winning the All Ireland Club Championship. Their almost automatic qualification for it every year is a bit of an advantage too compared to real club teams in England and France.

Sure Leiscter and Toulose qualify every year as well. The qualification advantage is well mitigated by the minuscule playing numbers relative to both those countries

woeful post

playing numbers mean fuck all for rugby

Humphries is the sort of fella that puts milk in his museli if you know what I mean

Your right they donā€™t. What was I thinking.

:lol:

apology accepted

hardly anyone plays rugby in NZ and Australia yet they are the best countries out there

So, the USA (where no one has even heard of the fucking sport) has more senior male rugby players than Aus.
Japan has twice as many as NZ.
Ireland has more than Wales.

No great fan of Rugby myself, but fuxake, but that is quite the load of unmitigated shite you just posted.

Ireland has more players than NZ - thats a fact

American Eagles are big underachievers imho.

The only thing that that chart proves is that different countries obviously have wildly varying ways of deciding that constitutes a ā€œregisteredā€ player, and particularly wildly varying ideas about what defines a ā€œsenior maleā€ rugby player.
Even the mildly retarded among us would look at the numbers on that chart and scoff.

so how do NZ rugby and Ireland rugby differ?

What the numbers tell me is that Irish players are pussies and the Kiwis arenā€™t.

yes- thats what the facts are pointing at

Senior players in Ireland need to look into their souls and wonder why theyā€™re inferior to their Kiwi counterparts.

On the surface this thread doesnā€™t reflect well on me. However I was made aware of some relevant information about the writer of that anti-rugby article and while I shared the sentiments of that piece I chose to express my difficulties with him by disagreeing with the specific article.