Could they not be used? Like @TheUlteriorMotive said, cancelling or removing books should be the last resort
Books get added and removed from the curriculum all the time as times change.
Itās just unnecessary to subject kids of any colour to the word in junior cert English, especially in the times we live in
I disagree.
Iād also say removing books, or any form of art in any scenario, because a minority (or a minority of a minority judging by how many complaints were received) is a bad road for society to go down
1 Like
If that are no black kids in the class can the book be used? A simple yes or no will suffice.
You disagree English can be taught at a junior cert level without using that word?
White kids donāt need to be subjected to the word either pal and may be equally uncomfortable having to read it out in class
No thatās not what I meant and Iām fairly certain you know that at this stage.
I disagree with the book being removed solely because it contains a word
It isnāt. Itās been suggested to remove it because that word is still very much in use and very much causes distress to people.
Racism didnt get fixed because people read to kill a mocking bird.
Imagine getting called that on the way to school, then hearing a school friend using it in English from a book that was written about last century. Man thatās depressing as fuck
1 Like
Did it get fixed cos they didnāt read it?
Itās commonly regarded as the great American novel. Would you pull Shakespeare.
Shakespeare is much more racist
Iāve never said anything should be pulled.
The discussion needs to be had though. Blithely dismissing it and hiding behind cancel culture isnāt the way forward either
The 16th and 17th century will do that to a man.
Itās an English course. To study the great works. Once you pull on the thread of what is acceptable to read and study a lot of things unravel.
There is a follow up book written years later from perspective of the daughter. That could be studied too.
2 Likes
With respect, itās fairly clear that the lads here are happy to have the discussion, the problem just appears to be that the discussion has ended with a conclusion that a few posters donāt agree with.
What unravels if you remove books that have that word in them from junior cert English?
1 Like
The poor fucking white kids too! Generations of traumatised white kids who had to read the N word in TKAMB
There are plenty of serious critics who spent their life arguing that great literature had to have a moral purpose.
1 Like
I didnt have to read it in the times of black lives matter mate.
People are a lot more socially aware now than they have ever been.
Remove it from books and then the kid puts in his ear phones on his journey home and listens to a load of black fellas using the word.
6 Likes
NWA arenāt on English syllabus as far as I know and what a person chooses to indulge in is different from what is prescribed on a curriculum