He made clane shite of WOD in a club game in November 2022, he’ll always be fondly remembered for that.
I just think a clever manager at least waits a few weeks and lets things settle before doing something like that. Not like there’s a rush.
By all accounts he’s ringing the clubs to send in players for trials in November too so it seems like he has no idea who is actually better than these lads he’s dropping.
I can see the whole thing blowing up.
There could be a fairly absurd situation too this winter where lads like Tobin, Hartley, Spain and Jack Power will be part of a Waterford winter training panel but sitting on the bench for Ballygunner while the lads starting in the Ballygunner forward line will for the most part have been deemed surplus to requirements by Molumphy.
There’s a clatter of lads in Waterford who have had the bones of a decade at it. While you dont scrap them all - you just need s handful of the right ones for experience. The new manager could give the old hands a year and then what, bin them anyway next year and have to go again? There’s no sympathy in this game for anybody…
get young hungry players in and build a team over a couple of years. Waterford have a few young guns coming- whether they’re good enough for senior who knows but as great as Tadgh was, he’s 32 with 3 ACLs behind him. Gleeson won’t even attempt to get fit. Hogan is shit and Dessie hasn’t done much in 2 years… time waits for no man.
Hopefully he’ll prove us all wrong but it looks like amateur hour thus far. The open trials are an anachronism but looked more like a ham-fisted publicity move initially. Now it seems they might actually be a serious part of the plan.
Be a great craic if the lads he drops turn up for the trials.
It could be laughable seeing some clubs pushing domestiques forward for trials with their best players sitting at home.
Didn’t Cahill do open trials in Tipp? Or some sort of trial game series?
That was Colm Bonnar
Colm Bonnar brought back the Miller Shield.
To be fair several lads who played in it went on to play in the 2025 All Ireland win but he didnt discard ten of the best players in the county before it either.
Kiely basically done open trials in 2016 didnt he?
Exactly, the only correction i’d make on Dessie is not 2 years, more like 5 years. Time for a rebuild.
I wouldn’t be reading too much in to the trials thing either.
Molumphy is shrewd enough and lives amongst the people in the county, I’d give him the benefit that he knows what he’s at. The incumbent panel of players haven’t got out of Munster, so what’s he meant to do, keep picking the same players with a few token ins/outs?
Practically all over 30 and almost all haven’t done anything at inter-county level in years.
Dessie can have no complaints if he’s axed as well.
TdeB has been a great servant but with accumulation of all the serious injuries, he’s looked off the pace for last 2-3 years too.
Not sure if Prunty has a future either. He’s permanently injured now too.
This would still be my view on it from earlier in the year.
Now is not the time for Waterford to be gutting the panel.
This news might inadvertently help some players from other Munster counties make up their minds about committing for next year as it feels like Waterford will be even more of a gimme two points than usual making the route out of Munster easier than ever.
I think getting Prunty back fit and in the side is crucial for Waterford 2027. Mark Fitzgerald at full back just won’t do as evidenced this year, but having Prunty at 3 thus releasing Fitz to 6 or even further afield makes them far more balanced IMO.
A fit and injury free Prunty would be a huge boost. He seems to be almost permanently crocked though.
Mark Fitzgerald is not a full back.
A highly rated S&C on board this year, we’ll see if that improves the likes of Prunty, Daly et al.
“Manager gets rid of players who are past it or never had it”
The halcyon days of the Ballymacarbry ladies 42 in a row Waterford Senior football championships from 1982-2023, a fading memory now. A third successive final defeat last night, this time most ignominiously to what was effectively the Ballygunner Camogie team in the colours of Gaultier, appearing in their first ever final and really just warming up for the serious business of trying to dethrone DLS in the Senior Camogie Final this day week.
Lots of Gaultier flags up in Dunmore this week. The locals are really getting on board.
There were a few Gaultier flags at Ballygunner cross this week too for the ladies football final, which was interesting. It was remarked to me by a prominent Gaultier GAA man that the men would never have put out a Gaultier flag in Ballygunner territory under any circumstances and would have have been too proud to do so anyway. The LGFA club in Gaultier was only founded 12 years ago. I’m told there’d be a fair few outsiders involved there some of whom wouldn’t have any time for hurling/camogie and were only waiting for that chance.
The DLS v Gailtir Camogie final should be a good game next week and I’ll go into it. They’ve met in final last 4 years and very little in it. A good bit of needle after building up, they don’t like each other and there’ll be a decent crowd in at it. DLS after their breakthrough first win in 2022 have won 3 of those 4 and really should be going for 5 in a row next week. Gailtir snatched 2024 final with a smash and grand 1-3 in injury time after trailing all the way.

