Id think the more responsible parents would sacrifice their 29 year old son coming home with the local gaa gossip in order to benefit his overall development afar
I find the parish rule sectarian
1 Like
A proper parental unit needs to threaten to omit their offspring from inheritance for the benefit of their local club imo
3 Likes
How good is Mannion now? Simplistic I know any club team would do well to hold him and Shane Walsh. Must be chasing an All Ireland.
They came pretty close to winning the AI last year without Mannion or Walsh. You’d think a transfer for a GK would be a priority after thr way they threw it away that day.
As an aside Mannion is class. Gave the best individual display in a county final Ive seen 2/3 years ago vs Judes. Must have got 1.7 from play
2 Likes
Odd alright. There was a high profile transfer last season between a Cork club and a Limerick club with no residency involved and not a peep about it here apart from a few of @thelimericks guffawing
The clubs maintained a dignified silence which helped I guess
1 Like
Did it not destroy the fabric of the GAA?
1 Like
I actually think that the price of housing in Galway will push people back out again. A city bypass would do more for the rural clubs in Galway than 5 Shane Walshes.
City clubs are all bad, rooral clubs are all good mate. Fall the fuck in.
4 Likes
It’s the rightly or wrongly we are debating.
It is all conjecture though. Maybe it’s just convenient for both. Lads here saying sure it’s only 4 or 5 games have no idea. You don’t get to be a Shane Walsh without absolute commitment. He wouldn’t brook rocking up on match day for the start. He’d be all in or all out. I’d say he’s exhausted and burnt out. He probably fancies a break, and I’m sure he fancies a chance to commit to mingling with locals in Dublin where for better or worse he is committed for at least two years. I don’t think either has done anything wrong. Maybe the club made an offer? So what? Maybe Shane accepted, again it’s no big deal.
There’s nothing in the world better at manufacturing outrage than the GAA.
It’s not like he transferred to corofin.
1 Like
Inter-county GAA ended on July 24th.
Nature abhors a vacuum.
People want to talk about inter-county GAA. They want to argue furiously about inter-county GAA. It is a national pastime, an obsession. Traditionally the space between matches allowed for saturation level discussion and analysis by ordinary followers. By the end of the week followers would be intricately familiar with every movement of every player in every minute of the previous weekend’s match.
But the championship season just gone did not allow that. The rushed nature of it was such that there was no time for absorption. Matches flew past like the name plates of stations at which the express train you are on is not stopping…Fonthi…vroom…Hazelha…vroom…Salli…vroom…Newbr…vroom…
There might be more podcasts than ever before, but the rushed nature of the calendar led to information overload. Before, people would go deep into the underbelly of a match. Controversies would last for weeks. Now they skim read like Twitter scrolling. No time to settle. No absorption. No depth to the season. Just a blur.
And now it’s over, and it feels like we’ve eaten an undersized portion of overpriced pasta at a restaurant. No starter. No dessert. The appetite not whetted. Unsatisfying.
So nature is filling the vacuum with what people want. The managerial merry go round has found a hidden power setting nobody knew it had, and we are on board.
The Shane Walsh transfer is a major controversy, not because any of us genuinely give a shit - we don’t - but because we need it to be a major controversy, we need it to be, we need it to be. We need it to be something communal that engages people from every corner of the island.
Because there’s nothing else to chew properly on. Club round robins in front of three men and a dog replacing the glorious seven week stretch of All-Ireland semi-finals and finals of August and September in front of 70 or 80 thousand people roaring like bears at Croke Park, it’s like nibbling on one digestive biscuit when it’s 9pm and you haven’t eaten properly all day, it’s like Villagers at Whelans replacing Oasis at Knebworth.
The Shane Walsh transfer. The one last vestige of excitement and anger and dopamine in what is now a zombie summer.
10 Likes
You need a hobby. Get you out of yourself.
A terrific piece of writing.
I can picture myself on that train.
7 Likes
I find myself nodding in agreement with this synopsis, I particularly liked the Digestive biscuit analogy. You certainly have your moments. 
2 Likes
How many “ Cashel “ lads are playing with Cashel? Not a whole pile
Transfers are part and parcel of the landscape in South Tipperary. They treat GAA like junior soccer
1 Like
This is the case in point.
Shane could have timed it all so much better.
He could have expressed this feeling earlier in the year as opposed the week before Dublin championships are kicking off?
If he was able to tour up and down for County training I’m sure he could have at least toured back down for club matches? Why not train with Crokes and transfer once his club championship in Galway was done?
Why did he get a PR man to put out a Statement?
The level of disrespect shown to his club is off the charts.
By all means transfer next January when you’ve seen out the season. If Crokes want him that badly they’ll wait.
The hassle he’ll cause to a small community is needless and plain disrespectful.
The cheek of him to state for cameras recently that the club was what really mattered, winning with lads he grew up with.
The Association should make the same rule cutoff for all transfers and this shit acting could be curtailed or at least carried out in the off season.
5 Likes
You’re some gom if you believe that tripe you posted there
Cahill has paid his dues in spades. His head was turned though in much the same way as Walsh’s has been here.
Liam has matured some amount tbf. You’d imagine Walsh at 29 would have more smarts but alas….