I think the perfect format has to involve league feeding into championship.
So top two tiers in wan champo.
Division 1 top 4 teams at end of the league are drawn to play bottom 4 teams in divsion 2. Next 4 seeded spots go to provincial winners* or if they are already in top 4, 5th in division one, etc. They will play top 4 in two or whoever is left in one.
*Provincial finals will be between the top two teams in each province based on their finishing league postion. So this year it would have been Mayo v Galway, Kerry v Cork, Dublin v Louth, Tyrone vs Monaghan.
Format as follows;
Round 1 16 teams in their seeded match ups. 8 winners advance. These 8 winners play each other again, leaving 4 winners in the QFs and 4 losers.
8 Losers playoff to give 4 winners. These 4 play the 4 losers from the winners side for a chance at QF.
This will be run off at a nice clip to disadvantage losing teams and make winning first two games a big benefit giving you a much needed week off, while losers toil. We can stagger it though so that 4 games one weekend, 4 next weekend and winners and losers from this side, staying on the same side of the draw so everyone is in a similar boat. Feeding into all Ireland semis a week apart as is the correct format. All the saved time can be used to stretch things out a bit.
The first 6 weeks would be;
Week 1. Side A
Week 2. Side B
Week 3. Side A (winners vs winners, losers vs losers)
Week 4. Side B (â)
Week 5. Side A (losers of âwinners vs winnersâ vs winner of âloser vs loserâ) Teams that have won twice have a bye week.
Week 6. Side B (â)
Week 7. QFs of side A
Week 8. QFs of side B
Week 9. SFs of Side A
Week 10. SFs of Side B.
Week 11. Off (hurling championship final)
Week 12. Off (stick on the Tailteann cup final this weekend0
Week 13. Box office final
Thatâs basically three months. Start in mid May, finish in mid August. Exact same format for hurling, two weeks earlier start of May, to start of August.
This format with the sides decided early, means the draw is box office, but also being seeded in the top 4 becomes very important to avoid other big dogs, similarly being seeded in the next 4 will be an advantage also. I would be open to provincial winners getting the top 4 spots in seeding to embiggen the provincial championships, but that would give Kerry, Dublin etc a massive advantage and devalue the league. We might give them home advantage or something as well.
New format will condense things nicely so we can leave a break between league and championship and allow time for the provincial finals to be played without fear of it interfering in the rest of it.
Finish up the league start of April, you can have a final if you want.
Provincal finals over the next two weeks, with teams involved in the league final not out the following week. Should it happen like this year, that Mayo and Galway say, are going to be both the provincial finalists and the league finalists. Then box office, double title match.
I think the seeding element, the time off after, plus the history attached, would make the provincials keenly contested.
You could congest that bit and start the league a couple of weeks later also.
In the unlikely event that a team from outside the top two leagues is one of the top two teams in the league for a province. Then, should they win their provincial final, the bottom team in division 2 goes down to Tailtean.
Two would still be promoted and relegated between league divisions.
Iâm not firmly set on this, but I wouldnât have D3 league winners put into the All Ireland proper that year, and bottom two teams in D2 in Tailteann. I would leave D3 winners in Tailteann. They would be promoted and play in championship next year. Relegated teams would be punished the following year by not being in championship, rather than punished in the year of relegation.
Second promotion spot would be the Tailteann winners. If it is the same team that take both promtion spots, the second place in the league and losing Tailteann finalists playoff. If the same team Mayoâd the shit out of it and came second in the league and lost the Tailteann final, then third in the league would get the playoff spot.
Should a 4th divsion team win the Tailteann, they would be promoted straight to two, with the knock on effect of carnage behind them, as third from bottom in D3 league finds themselves in D4 all of a sudden. Carnage, i.e. knock on effects for people not even involved in games is always good.
I think that has something for everyone, the only argument against it is that say Limerick footballers will never make a Munster final in this setup, and that is true, and that is a drawback. But something has to give