?
Ger “Redser” O’Grady
Paul Galvin would walk on to any all time Munster hurling team so leaving the Kingdom out is stupid.
The creme de la creme being mentioned here so far. 
From Cork
Mark Landers
Mickey O’Connell
Pat Hartnett
From Limerick
Mike O’Brien
Clem Smith
Donie Ryan
My tuppence worth, I am not picking a team rather my 3 best players from each county off the top of my head.
Tipperary
Jimmy Doyle
John Doyle
Eoin Kelly
Waterford
Tom Cheasty/Seamus Power
Ken McGrath
John Keane
Cork
Christy
JBM
Ray Cummins
Limerick
Mackey
Cregan
C Carey
Clare
Jimmy Smyth
Sean McMahon
Tony Kelly
[QUOTE=“Special Olympiakos, post: 1018502, member: 366”]My tuppence worth, I am not picking a team rather my 3 best players from each county off the top of my head.
Tipperary
Jimmy Doyle
John Doyle
Eoin Kelly
Waterford
Tom Cheasty/Seamus Power
Ken McGrath
John Keane
Cork
Christy
JBM
Ray Cummins
Limerick
Mackey
Cregan
C Carey
Clare
Jimmy Smyth
Sean McMahon
Tony Kelly[/QUOTE]
What age are you? Have you even seen most of them play?
Quaid.
Reale.
Richie.
Hickey.
Rasher.
Ciaran.
Davey Clarke.
Hoola
Clem Smith
Hannon
Banger
Kirby
Shocks
Dowling
Squiddy
My Grandfather and an auld boy from Castlecomer whos opinions on hurling I rate very highly both reckon that Mick Roche was as good as any hurler they had ever seen. Long before my time, did anyone on here ever see him play? @Fagan ODowd?
Who would you push out for him though? Hardly John Keane?
Probably as you couldn’t drop Clem Smith
My father would be of that generation and speaks of Roche as one of the best he ever saw.
I watched a video of the 1968 final, which Wexford won, but Roche was imperious that day. Seemed years ahead of his time in the way he played but that’s my only experience of seeing him hurl.
- Brendan Cummins Tipp
- Damien Reale LK
- Brian Lohan Clare
- Brian Corcoran Cork
- Mark Foley LK
- Seanie McMahon Clare
- Tony Browne Wd
- Tommy Dunne Tipp
- Ciaran Carey LK
- Jamesie O Connor Clare
- Ken McGrath Wd
- Tony O Sullivan Cork
- Joe Deane Cork
- Eoin Kelly Tipp
- John Mullane Wd
Best 15 I can pick going on the criteria & the players I have seen in my lifetime hurling.
[QUOTE=“Special Olympiakos, post: 1018502, member: 366”]My tuppence worth, I am not picking a team rather my 3 best players from each county off the top of my head.
Tipperary
Jimmy Doyle
John Doyle
Eoin Kelly
Waterford
Tom Cheasty/Seamus Power
Ken McGrath
John Keane
Cork
Christy
JBM
Ray Cummins
Limerick
Mackey
Cregan
C Carey
Clare
Jimmy Smyth
Sean McMahon
Tony Kelly[/QUOTE]
[QUOTE=“Esteban de la Sexface, post: 1018515, member: 2695”]Quaid.
Reale.
Richie.
Hickey.
Rasher.
Ciaran.
Davey Clarke.
Hoola
Clem Smith
Hannon
Banger
Kirby
Shocks
Dowling
Squiddy[/QUOTE]
[QUOTE=“carryharry, post: 1018666, member: 1517”]1. Brendan Cummins Tipp
2. Damien Reale LK
3. Brian Lohan Clare
4. Brian Corcoran Cork
5. Mark Foley LK
6. Seanie McMahon Clare
7. Tony Browne Wd
8. Tommy Dunne Tipp
9. Ciaran Carey LK
10. Jamesie O Connor Clare
11. Ken McGrath Wd
12. Tony O Sullivan Cork
13. Joe Deane Cork
14. Eoin Kelly Tipp
15. John Mullane Wd
Best 15 I can pick going on the criteria & the players I have seen in my lifetime hurling.[/QUOTE]
That Castlecomer mention got me thinking about that song “The Greatest Game Of All” by John Duggan from the album “The mighty Game”.
Is it possible to upload MP3s on here?
[QUOTE=“Joe Player, post: 1027868, member: 2692”][/QUOTE]
[QUOTE=“carryharry, post: 1018666, member: 1517”]1. Brendan Cummins Tipp
2. Damien Reale LK
3. Brian Lohan Clare
4. Brian Corcoran Cork
5. Mark Foley LK
6. Seanie McMahon Clare
7. Tony Browne Wd
8. Tommy Dunne Tipp
9. Ciaran Carey LK
10. Jamesie O Connor Clare
11. Ken McGrath Wd
12. Tony O Sullivan Cork
13. Joe Deane Cork
14. Eoin Kelly Tipp
15. John Mullane Wd
Best 15 I can pick going on the criteria & the players I have seen in my lifetime hurling.[/QUOTE]
I like you left out the rock
Did you ever see Mick Roche hurl, @Joe Player ?
?
No one can leave the rock out