We did this about a year ago on the old forum so I thought I’d see how many of us have changed our minds in the meantime.
I’d go for
Buffon
Zambrotta Nesta Mertesacker Lahm
Gattuso Essien
Kaka Ronaldinho
Drogba Eto’o
Not sure about the full backs but can’t think of anyone better to be honest at the moment. It’s lacking a bit of width in midfield but Zambrotta and Lahm will get forward anyway and Kaka and Ronaldinho would play both wide and narrow.