Bandage wrote:
A terribly disappointing night for Celtic and a reality check if ever there was one. Sure weâre probably the slickest passing side in Europe on our day but weâre not consistently the best side in the continent as of yet. The most annoying aspect of the defeat was the elementary mistakes for the goals we conceded.
Scotty Brown gave a dodgy pass to Mick for the first but the first 5 minutes of an away champions league tie is not the time for your centre back to try bring the ball out of defence. As for the second, I have never liked our zonal marking system at the back, even when we played 3-5-2 under OâNeill and if any striker risked going for a header heâd be nearly decapitated by Mjallby, Balde or Valgaeren, and this cost us again last night. Anyone who knows anything about Serie A will know how prolific Lucarelli is in the air and to have Naylor on the back stick marking him was asking for trouble.
Fair enough it was a cracking header although having conceded headed goals at the far post at Falkirk, Moscow and now Donetsk, and each time to a striker latching on to one of our small full backs, itâs surely time for our centre backs to take responsibility for picking up the strikers for crosses rather than one covering the near post and the other the centre area in line with the penalty spot.
We looked distinctly better when Hartley came infield but if truth be told they had the better chances throughout and we were quite fortunate to escape a heavier defeat. Head-to-head record could be important in what looks like being a tight group so in that sense avoiding a 3 or 4 goal defeat might be crucial when we give them a thumping in Glasgow.
Ratings:
Boruc - 5.783: Couldnât be faulted for either goal (even though Rocko inexplicably tried to do just that for the first) and made two quality saves after that.
Wilson - 2.471: Not good enough in either half. Didnât get close enough to their players to prevent balls coming into the box and his own delivery was poor on the overlap.
Caldwell - 6.239: A solid shift by the much maligned centre back. A series of good challenges and blocks and was easily the best of the overworked back four.
McManus - 3.558: Messy play for the first goal and though he tried hard as always things didnât improve much for him from then onwards.
Naylor - 2.362: All at sea in the first half. Stood off them, never marked, tracked runs or tackled. Big improvement in the second half though.
Naka - 3.247: Very poor display by his own high standards. Sloppy passing at times and generally very tentative throughout.
Brown - 3. 638: Started badly and continued in that vein. Quite lucky not to be sent off after making a number of reckless tackles. Some of the people building him up on this thread need to take a good look at themselves. The bhoy has it all to prove.
Donati - 5.593: One of our better players on the night. Put himself about and made some surging runs forward.
Hartley * - 6.437: Star man. Steadied the ship when he came into the centre and showed a massive appetite for work in the trenches as well as being very neat on the ball.
McDonald - 5.712: Another of the few to come out of the game with any credit. Held it up admirably, had a decent effort turned away by their keeper and showed constantly fotr the ball.
Vennegoor of Hesselink - 5.328: Caused them a lot of problems in the air and worked tirelessly but the cold facts are he had two free headers from 8 yards out and didnât hit the target with either.
Subs:
MackEddy (copyright Liam Brady) - 4.563: Was pitched into a losing battle and wasnât able to turn things around.
Killen - 2.984: Put himself about which translates into âfouled the opposition constantlyâ. Missed a one-on-one after 86 minutes.
Zurawski - Not on long enough to be rated.
So, all in all thereâs probably a few positives to be taken out of the game. At least Chris Killen is now cup-tied in the Champions League so itâs unlikely that one of the Spanish or Italian sides will try to take him off us in January. We also kept the scoreline down and could have taken a more severe beating. Other than that it made for quite depressing viewing. The ante has been upped and it more or less means weâll need to take 4 points off Benfica, beat Donetsk at home and get a good result in one of the Milan games. Speaking of which our run of games adds a bit of pressure with Milan at home next followed by a trip to Lisbon. I have every faith in the manager and the team and expect them to turn things around.
Agree with most of those ratings Bandage but Iâd have Naylor significantly lower than Wilson.
I didnât blame Boruc for the first goal, I just said if he had stayed on his line heâd have saved it because Brandao shot from outside the box in the end. The problem was he couldnât be sure that Caldwell would make it across to force him into hitting it early.
The goals weâre conceding at the back post are getting extremely repetitive. Itâs so easy for their strikers to drop onto our full backs and weâre doing nothing about it. Brandao did it at the other post later on in the first half and should have scored.