NO POINT IN CONDEMNING TRAPATTONI
by Denis Irwin
YES, I could lay into Giovanni Trapattoni’s stewardship of the Irish team this morning. The football he has this team playing is hard to watch, it is uninspiring and young, flair players like James McCarthy, James McClean and Seamus Coleman seem to be judged harshly by the boss when it comes to picking his teams.
But I ask you this, would you prefer to be a Scottish, Welsh or Northern Ireland supporter today - our neighbours who have played just two World Cup qualifiers and are more or less out of it already.
Each of those countries will have to win every remaining qualifier game if they are to reach Brazil 2014. For Trap’s Ireland, life is much better. A draw against the Germans next month will do us fine. Beat the Faroes away in our next match after that and we’d have seven points in the Group and be ready for the crunch games against Sweden and Austria next March.
Note, I wrote next March - that’s five and a half months after we play Germany and the Faroes. A lot can happen in football in that time and many more Irish players may have come to the fore.
Wounds
It’s a much better scenario than Scotland, Wales or Northern Ireland face where they have away matches ahead in Serbia, Croatia or
Portugal from which they must now win three points. But I’m not going to defend Trap to the hilt because he has not always helped himself.
The worst of his self-inflicted wounds is poor communication with his team and squad that is seeing players receive mixed messages about their future and what he wants of them when in an Irish shirt. It is a lesson the FAI must learn too. If they go beyond Ireland or Britain for Trapattoni’s eventual replacement, that coach must have perfect English. I said the Boys in Green are hard to
watch, but that is the price of being hard to beat, which is where Ireland lie now. It is also very difficult to watch at home where we are supposed to be the aggressor chasing goals.
We’d love it if teams came on to us, but they just won’t do that in international football. At home you have to make your own chances - and our system is not great for that. Maybe that’s why the crowds at the Aviva to watch this Irish team are so poor over the last 18 months. But I wonder would the crowds be any better if we were knocking the ball about, playing good football, and out of the qualifying chase after a couple of matches. You know the answer to that - they wouldn’t.
Trap has set us up so that when we go out on the pitch, home or away, everyone knows what they are doing and this may be behind his reluctance to use shining new talent such as McCarthy (left) or McClean the moment they present themselves.
Style
He wants them to have four or five friendlies to bed in, before they go into a big competitive game like Germany. But it can take 18 months for a player to play in five friendlies. I sense too, from some of the quotes you read, that the Italian would be willing to play a different style of football, if the quality players were there.
But he’s making the best use of what he has and in almost getting Ireland to a World Cup, andgetting them to the Euro 2012 finals, you have to say he’s doing a decent job. Remember that Aiden McGeady, at Spartak Moscow will be Ireland’s only Champions League player this season.
That’s where we stand and we’re trying to qualify against Sweden or Austria who have more such experienced players in Europe’s top flight. I think Trap will fail to get us to Brazil in the end, but only because we’ve drawn a very hard group. The Germans will win it and we’re trying to get past Sweden and Austria for second place and even then, we’ll have to win a play-off.
But there are groups in the qualifying that we could have got out of, we just didn’t have a slice of luck in the draw this time around.