Cork v Waterford - All Ireland Hurling Semi-Final 2'17

Is this hurlings version of eye gouging?

Official all clear for Ozzie.

1 Like

Good news.

Sanity prevails.

It is a bit of a joke, he was so stupid for doing it, especially considering all the furore in the build-up. But it will make for a better final if he’s there.

Yeah we might keep it picked out to Galway now.

Pick away

All that remains now is for James Ownes to say he is not happy with his performance in the semifinal, and should not have sent off Conor Gleeson.

1 Like

I would say yes, ban it from the game. What Walsh was doing was a blight on the game, if every defender started doing it and got away with it it would ruin play. It’s. A simple rule and it’s not difficult to stick to the rule, just wipe it out.

1 Like

You couldn’t make it up.

Conor Gleeson had to go pal,

He should have stood up and smirked at Horgan as they’d the game won.

Its tough on him…but you cant strike out like that.

Dan Shanahan the latest to be caught up in the helmet interference controversy.

12 Likes

That doesn’t look great at all.

1 Like

Why is Derek wiping his head?

Very weak article by Jackie today about the All Ireland final build up. 85% of it about what you need to do differently to make sure you’re properly prepared (shutting yourself off from the world for 3 weeks etc) before the last 15% shifts to a “treat it like any other game and don’t be consumed by it” conclusion. Just about to check out PM’s offering in the Examiner now.

2 Likes

Waterford won

Have you got through it yet? A lot of guff to say that the the sweeper success shouldnt be based on the result of a game with a man sent off. Oh and plenty of superiority “Kilkenny are better” type innuendo throughout too. A real “you’re not as good as you think you are” article to the good people of Waterford.

Furthering this point, Kilkenny people seem to be taking this Waterford team and their success this year particularly badly. You have heaps of former players and current “pundits” very much belittling them and their system at every turn. And their supporters seem particularly ungracious to their southern neighbours efforts. At least when Wexford were getting some modicum of success we got the faint praise of “second county” and “sure arent ye great for finally winning something” off them. No such false platitudes from Kilkenny these days to the Deise.

3 Likes

No doubt when Galway win Sheffield et Al will be crowing that this is proof that the sweeper system won’t win all Irelands, when all it proves is they lost to a better team.

On the flip side, I was hearing Waterford lads saying that by them beating Cork it was proof that you can win an All Ireland with the sweeper. Their logic being that once you get to the final anyone could win, so that was proof the sweeper can win the All Ireland.

Waterford are just better than Kilkenny, sweeper system or no. Some of Kilkenny’s best players just looked tired and drained this year, whereas Waterford are a young, fresh team with a few older lads who are also flying.

I haven’t read the article but I do think it’s fair to question whether Waterford would have won without the red card. They might have won anyway but we’ll never really know. The game was definitely in the balance when it happened.