Daily Debate: Cannavaro v Nesta

Two of the all time great defenders, from the same era, the same country and formed one of the greatest defensive partnerships we have seen an international level.

Cannavaro was a remarkable specimen, he was 5ft9 which was very small for a centre back but he played like he had springs on him, he was outstanding aerially and he was so powerful and tough as nails, you usually see his opponent crumpled once they ran into him. Cannavaro was extremely aggressive, he played with a will to win every ball and it was an approach that rarely let him down. Not sure how much of his tackles he’d get away with these days though.

Nesta was an absolute joy to watch, his reading of the game, his positional sense, his timing of the tackle was to perfection. Nesta didn’t do mistimed tackles, he might do the odd calculated foul but if he went to win the ball he won the ball. Like Cannavaro, Nesta had outstanding agility and balance, never ever look flustered and while he was a clean defender he had no problem getting his hands dirty when he had to.

  • Cannavaro
  • Nesta

0 voters

I’ll have to plump for Nesta, the best defender I’ve seen. I learned lot from him when I was playing myself, most of all to always point at the ball after you go to ground, whether you won it or not.

Cannavaro’s performance at the 2006 World Cup was absolutely sensational and is probably up there with Maradona in 86 as the greatest individual contribution at a major finals.

4 Likes

Cannavaro all day

Cannavaros play before del pierros goal vs Germany sums up how amazing he was

1 Like
5 Likes

Forged in Rome.

Immortalised in Milan.

Nesta.

And by fuck he was a fine fucking thing too.

1 Like

I think Nesta was better but Cannavaro had that spectacular element because of his leaps and because of his last ditch defending so I’ll vote for him on the appeal of that.

Canna-fucking-varo

Achieved perfection in 2006. Best defender I ever saw and by a country mile.

1 Like

Nesta had it all and was probably a better player, but I’d want Cannavaro in my team all day long. So, Cannavaro

I’ve gone for Nesta but this reminded me of Dunphy’s quote on Cannavaro “If Rio Ferdinand is worth 100 grand a week then this guy is worth 100 million a day”.

3 Likes

Nesta comfortably over his career .

Both had great doctors.

3 Likes

Dunphy called ronaldo a con

A phenomenal goal.

1 Like

Cannavaro is the only defender to ever win the ballon d’or but he never won the seria A or the champions league. That’s crazy

Cannavaro was still coming. He almost cleaned Totti out of it as well.

That was some team

1 Like

Juventus and presumably himself would dispute him not winning Serie A

They got stripped of it didnt they for match fixing?

Yeah, they don’t agree with that though. They count the 2 extra themselves

Would you count them?

Just followed up there and it turns out two other defenders have won the ballon d’or. Name them without google

Baresi and Beckenbauer?