Ireland v Luxembourg - the Piles Derby

Alan Browne isn’t better than McGeady anyway. It’s not even close. I get he’s never going to be picked now but the idea that McGeady wouldn’t have a field day against a Bundesliga 3 wing back is nonsense. We struggle to create chances but wouldn’t consider McGeady a better option than some of the pedestrian players we choose instead. And still talk about trying to play football the right way.

The football Kenny wants to play seems to be based on possession stats, not anyone actually doing anything on the ball.

1 Like

I’d take a has been over a never was. I’d take McClean bursting his gut over Alan Browne fixing his hair.

We were giving out about McGeady ten years ago ffs. And again they aren’t in competition for the same place. McGeadys having a good season in LEAGUE ONE. The same level as Bundesliga 3

2 Likes

Insightful. I’ll take that as a backtrack

Collins is probably our best performing striker at the moment which says a lot. Stevens was a regular under Mick and good for the last 2 years or so for Ireland

I thought lads were ball hopping about bringing McGeady back in… but my God they are genuinely trying to make a case for it… this really is rock bottom.

3 Likes

I haven’t backtracked. I don’t do backtracks, I double down and reiterate. I’d have McClean over a fud like Alan Browne any day.

Aiden Mc fucking Geady.

We have really hit rock bottom.

3 Likes

Beep beep beep beep

He’s 30, can barely run and is utterly shit. How is that building for the future?

I have seen very little ever of AB but in the last 2 games in saw good and bad .

He is game , honest and has a role but Jesus he has really poor feet and gives the ball away an awful lot .

His current level of club football seems about right .

McGeady should definitely be in the squad

1 Like

McGeady is criminally underrated in Irish football.

Id agree on McGeady but lads forget Shane Long’s goal v Germany was 6 years ago. Totally finished. For the games in June , Kenny should be brave and drop all the old guard.

He could be our Tadic.

Well Kenny’s first choice is injured and there’s not much other option. Long is worse at the moment if that’s who you’re advocating

He’s in League one because of wages. And exactly it’s the same level. So he might equally find tonight’s opponents aren’t too difficult for him. Why would we expect he’d struggle against Luxembourg? Because Browne and Collins and others found that level too tough a nut to crack.

Kenny Cunningham seems to have been convinced that this was a tough game tonight. They’re well organised but Christ we make it easy for them by doing nothing. And we don’t gamble or take chances on the ball and we aren’t picking players who do that.

I’m not expecting McGeady to be picked but I absolutely believe he’s an awful lot better than most of that squad and would create a lot more than the mediocrity we’ve picked instead.

2 Likes

McClean looks finished . Legs look utterly gone and also the bit of a scut I loved in him

1 Like

McClean is finished. He is Ireland and he is finished.

I don’t believe Long is worse than Collins.