Any hoops playing?
Rovers, Pats and Bohs had one player each in the starting XI. Troy Parrott of Tottenham did thisâŚ
Is Troy Irish or English?
Sean McDermott Street I think .
Heâs Irish.
Played for Belvo didnât he?
Nice by Parrott but he wouldnât want to repeat it .
Yes⌠he is a big unit .
Yes
Great to see Barry Coffey from Nenagh coming off the bench.
This is a seriously talented bunch
FOOTBALL | GEORGE CAULKIN
Winner, aggressor, motivator, enigma â Roy Keane is a fire that burns like no other
George Caulkin speaks to those who know Irelandâs assistant coach best to work out why one of footballâs most divisive figures still has a role to play
Keane has formed a successful double act at Ireland with OâNeill, who has no regrets about the appointment of his assistantMATTHEW ASHTON/GETTY IMAGES
The Times, October 12 2018, 5:00pm
Share
Save
âI honestly donât think anybody could have done what Roy did at Sunderland. He didnât just lift the dressing room, he lifted the city. Thatâs the difference. When somebody comes in and lifts a city, it can be the petrol that fuels a club.â Niall Quinn.
First things first; Martin OâNeill harbours no regrets, not about the complex, driven individual he chose as his assistant five years ago. As pressure builds around Ireland â after two heavy competitive defeats, there is a demand for results which does not quite reflect the teamâs limitations â much of the conversation centres on Roy Keane. It often does. The manager shuts it off. He feels âtotal vindicationâ about his decision.
Second things second; here we go again, felling more trees, coughing out newsprint, attempting to rationalise one of the most compelling and divisive sporting figures of his generation. The context this time? A treatment-room dispute between Keane and Harry Arter about fitness and commitment which led to the midfielderâs withdrawal from last monthâs international fixtures.
Keane initially made a huge impact at Sunderland, but things soon turned sourOWEN HUMPHREYS/PA
Irelandâs resources are so meagre that any alienation is fraught with risk and although Arter has returned for tonightâs Nations League fixture against Denmark and Tuesdayâs rematch with Wales, concerns gnaw away. Have we reached a point in the cycle where a warrior player who urged Manchester United to titles, this fire made flesh, has become more trouble than he is worth?
OâNeill pauses at that. âIâm glad you asked the question,â he says. âIâve never felt it that way. Look, I actually think weâve come a little way. Youâre always learning in this business. Someoneâs methods of getting the best out of people, it might not be suitable sometimes for a particular person, you know. It might not be. But the fact is that Roy and Harry have made up.
âAnd Iâve got to say, I would be disappointed if it put Roy into his shell. His time with the players â on the pitch when we train and around them afterwards â I wouldnât change that for anything. Youâre talking about a group of lads who had Roy as their poster-boy. Now theyâre getting to see him up close.â
Keane and OâNeill have a good working relationshipKIERAN GAVIN/GETTY IMAGES
It is not always pretty, but neither is football. A leaked conversation between Stephen Ward, the Burnley full back, and his friends, alleged that Keane had said to Arter, âYouâre f****** prick, youâre a c***, you donât even care, you donât wanna train.â On these pages, it prompted a blunt headline: âFew people have been less suited to coaching than this vile bully Roy Keaneâ.
Yet light dapples the shade and Keane is three-dimensional. Before Ireland played Italy in the European Championship finals, a victory which took them into the knockout phase, OâNeill delivered the team-talk while Keane âwas more personal,â Shay Given says, having âa word here and there, reminding people of their responsibilities and their jobs. There was no chest-beating or pulling doors off hinges.â
Rewind, reboot, recalibrate. It was late August 2006 and, in Quinnâs words, Sunderland were âbrokenâ, relegated from the Premier League with 15 points and now, after four league games and four defeats, bottom of the Championship. Quinn, who had played for Sunderland, fronted an Irish consortium which had bought the club. He was chairman and, temporarily, the manager.
Enter Keane. He and Quinn had been team-mates for Ireland, pushed apart after that extraordinary episode in Saipan when Keane left Irelandâs 2002 World Cup squad. Theirs was a convoluted relationship but the partnership thrived, Quinn promising enraptured supporters a âmagic carpet ride.â Six new players arrived on transfer deadline day. Uplift followed.
âWe had media requests to attend Royâs press conferences from China, Japan, Hong Kong,â Quinn says. âWhat Championship club would get that? Thatâs the reach he has, what he can bring. He just has this unbelievable presence.
âWhen he first came to Sunderland, we were still trying to sell 27 executive boxes. We organised a function for North East business people. Roy walked into the room and it fell silent. He worked that room and didnât hold back. We sold out in an hour and a half. He got in his car, went home. I could tell 100 stories like that. The guy has a phenomenal power.â
Quinn described Keane as having an âunbelievable presenceâAP
With gelignite beneath them, Sunderland soared as champions. âTo not know the league, to learn, to grab it and get promotion from a relentless division, Iâm telling you, thatâs a great effort,â OâNeill says. âRoy took it in his stride,â Quinn says. âHe put Sunderland on the map.â
David Connolly was top scorer that season. âRoy made it like a mini Manchester United,â he says. âThe place was buzzing, it was a wave of excitement. Everyone bought into it. It was a massive coup; a world class player, his first role in management, not too dissimilar to Steven Gerrard at Rangers. He harnessed the energy of the club.â
Keaneâs standards were exacting. âRoy would oversee training,â Connolly says. âHe would select the team and discuss tactics with his coaches, but they led the sessions. We spoke to people who were at United and it was similar; high-tempo, very competitive. Roy didnât suffer fools and it didnât matter who you were or what youâd done. You had to perform.â
Were there personal relationships with players? âThere was a feeling that if you had to talk to him too often he would probably think you were high maintenance,â Connolly says. How about empathy? âHe didnât have too much time for injured players, but thatâs fair enough. You were expected to play with niggles and thatâs fine, too.
âWhen my daughter was born, we were playing at home the following day and I was in the team hotel. It got to 10pm and I said to Roy, âMy wifeâs giving birth,â and he said, âOK, see you in the morning.â So I got my wife, drove to the hospital and was back at the hotel for breakfast at 8am. That was how you were expected to be. Again, fine with me, but not everybody would want to work that way.â
Sunderland finished 15th in their first season back in the Premier League, but the experience was wearing. In November 2007, they were beaten 7-1 at Everton. âI hardly left the bed for 48 hours,â Keane wrote in his autobiography. âYouâre advised to move on quickly, but I couldnât. I donât think I showered for two or three days.â He lacerates himself more than anybody. Anger is âpart of my personality,â he says and so, too, âthe self-destruct button.â
âWe all lack something,â Connolly says, âand, I donât know, maybe the strengths you have as a player and person can also be a weakness. That hunger, that desire, that will to win burns brighter in some than in others and that daily necessity to be striving is something Roy has in abundance. When youâre winning, itâs great. He has a great sense of humour and can be brilliant company.
âWhen itâs not going so well, it becomes trickier. Coping mechanisms and strategies arenât things you learn on courses. Youâre worrying about the whole club and your mood can infiltrate the whole club. I guess thatâs where it became hardest for Roy.â
Sunderland ended in sourness, but the club stayed up for a decade. âI wanted to leave my mark,â Keane said, âI donât think I quite did.â Many would disagree; it was explosive, special. Quinn says: âI remember saying to Roy once, âHey, weâve got to be a bit more certain about the players we buyâ and Roy went, âBack me and eventually weâll have 11 like me.â â The thought is terrifying and tantalising.
Keane has fallen out with several members of the Ireland squad during his time as assistant managerRYAN BYRNE/REX FEATURES
Ipswich Town, Keaneâs next posting, was wrong from the start. His âbiggest failing,â was recruitment, he said, but he âmanaged badly.â If he lived it again, he âwould try and enjoy it a bit more. Iâd try and be myself a bit more.â And: âI felt like an actor sometimes.â
Why Keane, 47, has to be âRoy Keaneâ is another conundrum, although his eagerness to learn under OâNeill and Paul Lambert at Aston Villa, hardly screams of ego. âTheir contrasting personalities worked really well,â Given says of Ireland. âMartin is very calm and analytical with a quiet authority, while Roy can have a bit of a temper and give you a rollicking.â Given calls it an âeffective combination.â
It felt right to OâNeill and still does. He had enjoyed punditry duties alongside Keane for ITV and there was shared history: Nottingham Forest, Brian Clough, Celtic. âHe was a strong-minded fellow, with a pretty strong opinion,â OâNeill says. âI believe Roy has unfinished business in management, but I also thought he might enjoy this role, working for a manager who was a generation older, someone he had some respect for.
âI liked what he could bring to the Irish side of things. I knew about Saipan and the divide, but Roy was an iconic figure, too, and as much as I believe I get players playing for me, the lovely side is that he would be dealing with players who idolised him. It turned out pretty well for us. We made it through to France, a brilliant experience. I felt total vindication for him coming on board.
Keane worked under Lambert at Villa before assisting OâNeill with IrelandTONY OâBRIEN/ACTION IMAGES
âRoy is fiery, thereâs no question about that, but letâs be fair. He had some great players alongside him at Manchester United, but he was the driving force and his team-mates were just as concerned about pleasing him as they were about pleasing Sir Alex Ferguson. I wouldnât want to diminish that. Iâd want to enhance it. So I know at times there can be a bit of friction and arguments, but thatâs up to me to manage. I wouldnât change it; not at all.â
Perhaps the other side of Keane, that yearning for perfection which mutates into imperfection, emerged following the World Cup qualifying play-off defeats to Denmark. Perhaps tension and scrutiny were all inflamed by that sapping 4-1 loss in Wales last month, but if Keane should sometimes retreat for a step or two, so should we. Sunderland was extraordinary. Ireland have over-achieved.
At his introductory press conference in 2013, Keane discussed his image. âIâm not some sort of animal,â he said. He was looking forward to working more closely with players. Like a friendly uncle? âI could be, yes,â he said. âIf things go well. If we are winning.â And if not? âJesus. Listen, you all have an uncle you donât really like, donât you?â Everybody laughed. Ireland need a win, but nobody craves it more than their assistant manager.
John Walters verified the WhatsApp here as a pundit on sky
The Under 19s have beaten the Dutch. The Delaney/Dokter vision coming to fruition.
Relegated from a made up competition
Will Eire be competing in the repechage next year?
I donât believe their demotion is confirmed. I think they can avoid relegation if they beat Austria by better than 1-0 and the Austrians fail to get something from Bosnia.
Relegated from playing friendlies
Ground football is on its uppers
Iâd have thought a rugby man would understand just how damn important friendlies are. These were full test matches with caps awarded and ranking points available.
Iâd have thought a rugby man would understand just how damn important friendlies are. These were full test matches with caps awarded and ranking points available.
No these are definitely plain old friendlies
John has a long term plan, no need to panic