Sister
He has 6 in fact!
How a planning row in An Taisce Limerick became a bitter defamation showdown
After a six-day trial rooted in local An Taisce disputes and leaked WhatsApp chats, a High Court jury has cleared Emma Gilleece of defaming Limerick solicitor Michelle Hayes in a series of tweets.
30th Oct, 2026 - 24 min read
Francesca Comyn
Legal Editor
In August 2021, Brian Leddin, Green Party TD for Limerick, became embroiled in a political scandal over comments he made on a private WhatsApp group about his ex-girlfriend being âunhingedâ and craving fame. The remarks, leaked to The Irish Mail on Sunday, were branded ârepulsiveâ and âmisogynisticâ by Catherine Martin, the then deputy leader of Leddinâs own party, but he was not sanctioned for them.
In 2024, Leddin lost his seat in the general election and later resigned from the Green Party over its decision to back Catherine Connolly in the presidential election.
Elisa OâDonovan, the former partner referred to in the messages, won a local seat for the Social Democrats in Limerick City West in 2019 and remains a councillor.
Last week, architect Marcus Mulvihill, the âwhistleblowerâ behind the controversy, gave a High Court jury the inside track on why he had decided to leak messages from the âtoxicâ WhatsApp group to five of its âvictimsâ.
While Mulvihill did not go to the newspapers, there is evidence the screenshots found their way to at least two other journalists before The Irish Mail on Sunday decided to go to print.
The scandal arguably helped to derail Leddinâs political career. It also added fuel to defamation proceedings brought by Limerick environmental solicitor Michelle Hayes against communications advisor, architectural historian, and contributor to RTĂ Culture Emma Gilleece.
âBullying and threatsâ
At one point Hayes, Mulvihill, and Gilleece had all been members of the Limerick branch of An Taisce.
Hayes claimed, in two separate defamation suits lodged in 2021 and 2023, that her reputation had been seriously damaged by 26 tweets Gilleece posted on X (formerly Twitter) on dates spanning June 2020 to June 2024. The tweets allegedly meant that she was a toxic, fake environmentalist, and a misogynist who engaged in bullying and threats in the course of her business.
Hayes is a solicitor with Hayes Solicitors Limerick, a family practice on Glentworth Street.
She also claimed the tweets meant that she had constructed a body called Environmental Trust Ireland as a device to get on the environmental group of a public participation network (PPN) in Limerick linked to the local authority.
Gilleece, whose followers on X ranged from around 10,000 to 12,000 at the relevant times, denied falsely and maliciously defaming Hayes. She relied partly on the defence of honest opinion and said that some of the tweets did not identify Hayes or referred to her sister Dr Breda Hayes, whom she had clashed with while they were both in An Taisce.
While represented by Hayes Solicitors Limerick, SocDem councillor OâDonovan also lodged defamation proceedings against Gilleece over certain tweets she had posted. She later withdrew the case before it went to court.
Among the allegedly defamatory tweets posted by Gilleece was a call in January 2023 for an apology from Cllr OâDonovan and Michelle Hayes for âselling transcripts of my private conversation in that group to the pressâ. An earlier tweet by Gilleece alleged that they had taken selective screenshots of yearsâ worth of the WhatsApp chat and spent âthe best part of six months going around to every paper to get that story publishedâ before they eventually found âthe raggiest of ragsâ.
One tweet claimed Hayes had âabused her skills as a solicitorâ. Others referred to âorchestratedâ legal proceedings lodged to keep Gilleece âgaggedâ or âsilencedâ. Yet another spoke of objections being raised to student housing in the âextremes of a housing crisisâ, and âtwo solicitors deciding whatâs developed in their neighbourhood in Limerick Cityâ.
One tweet simply read: âDing dong the witch is deadâ.
An Taisce: a âcult organisationâ
The trial opened before Justice Oisin Quinn and a High Court civil jury of nine men and three women on Tuesday, October 20. It ran for six days in Court 29 and heard from a total of five witnesses.
Acting for Hayes were senior counsel Ronan Lupton and barrister Michael OâDoherty, instructed by the plaintiffâs solicitor, her sister Breda Hayes of Hayes Solicitors Limerick.
Gilleeceâs legal team was led by senior counsel Mark Harty along with barrister Paul OâShea, instructed by Stephen Kelly Law.
First up to testify was Hayes, a solicitor in a family-run practice with expertise in planning and environmental law.
Separately, the jury heard she is also president of Environmental Trust Ireland, a voluntary group she co-founded in March 2019 that makes submissions in planning cases and raises challenges in the courts.
Successes include objecting to plans to expand the red mud (bauxite residue) waste area at Aughinish Alumina. The refinery rests beside areas of special conservation and has been linked with exporting alumina to Russia. In that case, High Court judge Justice David Holland told her Hayes had done a public service, she said.
She also opposed Irish Cementâs application for an Environmental Protection Agency licence for industrial emissions at its plant in Mungret by raising submissions at an oral hearing in 2020. The court heard children have nosebleeds near that particular area, and thousands took to the streets in Limerick to oppose the licence. Unfortunately, it didnât work out, she said.
Under questioning by her senior counsel Lupton, Hayes outlined her dealings with the Limerick branch of national heritage group An Taisce, which she joined in December 2018, along with her sister.
She described it in court as a âcult organisationâ that determined what planning objections got through.
She filled the position of acting chair during her time in the group when the chair became ill. She left in March 2020 over her opposition to a proposal for student accommodation at Punchâs Cross, near Mary Immaculate College in Limerick. Hayes said âall hell broke looseâ when she sent an email to the An Taisce branch flagging her intention to oppose the development on environmental grounds, including the existence of underground storage tanks and the siteâs link to the Shannon special area of conservation.
Michelle Hayes ran as an independent candidate for Limerick City in the 2024 general election.
Following pushback in emails from other An Taisce members, including Emma Gilleece, she said she opted to oppose the development in a private capacity rather than as an An Taisce representative.
An Bord PleanĂĄla ultimately refused planning for the site on the grounds the student accommodation was substandard with tiny bed spaces, but also because it was on the contaminated site of a former petrol station, she explained.
After the Punchâs Cross incident, the witness said she wrote a letter to Gilleece and another member of the group on July 15, 2019, raising the issue of bullying. She said Gilleece did not reply.
Asked about their previous interactions, Hayes said Gilleece had been condescending towards her, telling her that she and Brian Leddin would teach her how to use Google Docs.
In response to a bullying complaint, a person from An Taisce HQ in Dublin came down and spoke to the individual parties but, according to Hayes, a proper investigation was not carried out.
The An Taisce report concluded there was no evidence of bullying.
A profession of âtrust and integrityâ
In response to three tweets by Gilleece in 2020, including one about âexperts in bullying and threatsâ which Hayes maintained was a reference to the Hayes law firm, she decided to sue.
âMy reputation means everything to me,â she told the jury. She said she became a solicitor to help people and that her job involves a lot of pro bono work. It is a profession of trust and integrity, she explained. Her clients have to have confidence in her as a solicitor.
She said it was hard being âridiculed onlineâ and upsetting when people in Limerick saw the tweets. One post was pinned for 11 months.
Hayes said she knew Gilleeceâs âmobâ would be coming behind her. This was trial by social media, the court heard. She was silenced, she said, but now hoped to be vindicated by a jury of her peers.
In December 2020, she recalled meeting the architect Marcus Mulvilhill in OâConnell Street in Limerick. She remembered it because it was the winter solstice. He stopped her and mentioned the An Taisce WhatsApp Group he was a member of, that Leddin renamed âCompaĂąerosâ. He said he would send her some information, which he did by forwarding on screenshots of the group chat in early January 2021.
Hayes said she read a few pages but it was too upsetting. In March 2021 she saw extra screenshots of the group chat with a downloaded photo and a four-letter word beginning with âCâ written over her name. It was not Gilleece who had uploaded the picture but the jury was shown a remark she made in the group about using the picture as her new darts board.
âMisogynyâ and fake environmentalism
Hayes claimed she and her sister were clearly identifiable in another Gilleece tweet about how one of the most misogynistic things ever said to her was by a woman. She said they were also wrongly branded as âtoxic fake environmentalistsâ.
Even when Hayes instigated the first set of legal proceedings, Gilleece didnât stop posting on X, the court heard. She went on to accuse the solicitor of peddling the Leddin story to the newspapers. This was untrue, the court was told.
Another tweet on January 6, 2024 posted a pre-action cease-and-desist legal letter sent to Gilleece from Hayes Solicitors Limerick. It was viewed 119,000 times, the court heard.
âI have become a victim,â Hayes said in her testimony. Colleagues crossed the street to avoid her and when she did professional development CBD courses, she said she felt isolated.
The tweets were ânon-stopâ. She recalled it being particularly upsetting and hard after her mother died. It was two days before Christmas 2023 and Gilleece was âat it againâ. She had to write the eulogy and the family made a decision not to stream the funeral for fear of what Gilleece might do.
The Irish Cement challenge
Under cross-examination, senior counsel Mark Harty put it to Hayes that she had been criticised by a judge of the High Court in a costs hearing in the Irish Cement case in 2023.
Hayes had taken a judicial review as a litigant challenging the decision by the Environmental Protection Agency to grant Irish Cement a licence to burn waste products at its Mungret plant. The case was heard along with a separate but similar application from Sue Ann Foley, daughter of billionaire businessman and racehorse owner JP McManus.
Hayes had held a press conference after the case, saying she had nothing to gain from the legal challenge had they won.
Under cross-examination, it was put to Hayes that this wasnât accurate, as Hayes Solicitors would have been awarded costs. Because she was the applicant and the solicitor in the Irish Cement litigation, she would, in fact, have gained, he suggested. Her reply to the jury was that she was a salaried partner at her sisterâs law firm and had paid âŹ10,000 personally for photocopying in the judicial review proceedings.
Hayes said she had taken the case in her own name in Irish Cement and that it had gone to the commercial list of the High Court where it was scheduled to run for three days. The other person bringing a challenge was a billionaireâs daughter.
She said there were no regulations against solicitors bringing such a case.
It was explained to the jury that Dr Hayes was her solicitor in the current proceedings in order to save money, as it costs over âŹ100,000 to bring a defamation suit.
Counsel pointed out that unlike other kinds of cases, such as personal injury actions, anyone who takes an environmental case is entitled to a protected costs order under EU law. That means they donât have to pay the costs of the other side if they lose.
Under cross-examination
Further questioned by Harty, Hayes denied that Gilleeceâs claims of bullying and threats were in fact true, and stemmed from her taking it personally that An Taisce would not back her objections to the Punchâs Cross development.
This episode had prompted an email from Dr Breda Hayes, also a member of An Taisce, in July 2019, stating that as an officer of the court, Dr Hayes could not stand over or turn a blind eye to the âserious regulatory breachesâ that occurred in the local association. She put them on notice that there was a point when any reporting obligation she had would be triggered.
The email alleged âgroup bullyingâ and said if there was any undue haste to accelerate an AGM prior to December 2019, this would be responded to by way of court injunction, which would by necessity involve full details of what has happened in the Limerick local association emerging in a public forum, which would be damaging for An Taisce.
Hayes was asked whether this was a threatening email. She said it was a statement of fact. She did not say under questioning whether she had approved of the emailâs contents in advance.
Asked why she had sued Gilleece over the tweets and her sister had not, she replied that she was the person the public recognised as president of Environmental Trust Ireland.
Separately, she accepted that she had objected to an attempt by Gilleece to have the defamation proceedings heard in the Circuit Court, where damages are capped at âŹ75,000.
It also emerged in questioning that Hayes had contacted the gardaĂ at one point and had a solicitorâs letter sent to RTĂ because Gilleece had a reference to RTĂ Culture in her bio on X. Asked what the purpose of the letter was, Hayes said she hoped RTĂ would tell Gilleece that what she was doing was âvery wrongâ.
Gilleece subsequently removed the RTĂ Culture reference from her X profile but continued to contribute to RTĂ as an architectural historian. Her newly published book This Modern Love on 20th-century Irish architecture stems from that work with RTĂ. She also recently filmed a behind-the-scenes visit to the attorney generalâs office with presenter Brendan Courtney for Culture Night in September.
The WhatsApp group and âgossipâ
The second witness for Hayes was Marcus Mulivihill, an architect originally from Limerick who specialises in the restoration and reuse of derelict buildings. The jury heard that on his return to the city in 2017, he began working on a project around the future of the University of Limerick campus and was invited to join the local branch of An Taisce.
He soon became part of the local An Taisce WhatsApp group, created by Leddin.
His evidence was that he quickly became âpretty disillusioned with the groupâ. He joined because An Taisce gets a lot of public funding and he had an interest in major environmental infrastructure projects happening in the Shannon estuary. He told the jury the expansion of Aughinish Alumina was a âpsychotic environmental disaster waiting to happenâ and claimed there were high rates of pulmonary diseases because of Irish Cement.
In his view, the WhatsApp group became a place for people to gossip about peopleâs relationships and focus on âattacking rival socio-economic cliquesâ rather than on large environmental infrastructure issues.
When he got a job in Dublin working for the heritage department of the Office of Public Works, he disengaged and muted the group chat, which he found was âjust nonsense and very horrible behaviourâ.
On July 13, 2019, the day before Bastille Day, Mulvihill was in Paris when Leddin and Gilleece contacted him asking for his help to smooth the waters in a dispute with Michelle Hayes, whom he didnât know.
He unmuted the WhatsApp group and went through the messages. He said he noticed these people were organising social media attacks not just on Hayes but on about 20-30 people all around Limerick. There were, he said, a lot of anonymous online accounts.
Screenshot of the leaked WhatsApp group.
Screengrabbing certain passages within the group, Mulivihill said he passed them on to five different âvictimsâ that were being âterrorisedâ by bot accounts with one or two followers, including a FĂanna FĂĄil candidate. He said he had no relationship at all with these people. He just believed they were being subjected to toxic behaviour.
Under cross-examination, he rejected the suggestion that he had leaked selective details of private WhatsApp conversations and had been happy to âbetray the trustâ of the group. He said the messages showed clear targeting and abuse of people and that in a healthy society people should not be attacked for their views.
Describing himself as unaffiliated politically, he said he was also unhappy that a national organisation like An Taisce, he claimed, was being used to play media games and promote members of the Green Party.
The court heard he was removed from the WhatsApp group by Paul OâBrien in early 2020 when he started objecting to the âcarry-onâ. He denied he had decided to âexact revengeâ for his removal as he was not friends with anyone in the group and had already disengaged.
Under cross-examination, Mulivihill said he was unaware that Hayes had raised a bullying complaint with An Taisce against Gilleece in 2019 for not supporting an objection to the Punchâs Cross development.
Counsel suggested it was not unreasonable, when with friends, to be a little unmeasured and call someone rude names like a âbitchâ when they take pot shots at you. Mulvihill countered that this was not a private friends group but an An Taisce group.
Harty put it to Mulvihill that if a group of public servants like court registrars formed a WhatsApp group, it would still be a private group. He suggested the witness had not considered the context of the messages before riding in like âthe lone rangerâ.
A âpure ambushâ
As day two of the trial drew to a close, Elisa OâDonovan, a speech and language therapist and SocDem councillor, took to the stand. She described how she first met Hayes after she was elected in 2019 while out flyering homes in connection with a strategic housing development in her area of Limerick City West.
Not being from Limerick originally, OâDonovan said she had to do a lot of relationship-building, and found Hayes âvery knowledgeableâ with âreal expertise around planningâ.
The solicitor had given her guidance around a campaign to save the historic Curragower House, and had a âpassionâ for her community, she said.
OâDonovanâs evidence was that she did not know Gilleece but she had blocked her on social media when she started talking about her ânon-stopâ on social media.
The jury was sent out because Gilleeceâs senior counsel objected to this âoutburstâ by the witness which Hardy described as a âpure ambushâ of his client, of no direct relevance to the defamation claims advanced.
As the lawyers jousted in legal argument at the end of a long court day, Harty threw in a new objection: âI would ask Mr Mulvihill not to call me an arsehole from the back of the court.â
Justice Quinn said there should be no interventions of that sort, adding that he didnât want to have to make an order.
âHiddenâ sexist attitudes
It wasnât the only courtroom flare-up. The following morning, on Thursday, again in the absence of the jury, Lupton complained that a member of the public had approached Cllr OâDonovan the previous evening in court and said something âsomewhat inappropriate and possibly intimidatingâ, leaving her in some distress.
While challenging this account as a âgross mischaracterisationâ of what had occurred, Harty said this member of the public had agreed to stop attending the court sittings, obviating the need for any formal court order. The judge accepted this solution.
With the jury back in court, OâDonovan continued her testimony.
She said she had found Hayes to be âvery well respectedâ in her work for the environment but she noticed that changed when she ran for election in 2024. People who had previously spoken highly of her were more disparaging of Hayesâs character and credibility, the court was told.
Under cross-examination, OâDonovan said she wasnât aware that Hayes had been criticised in 2023 by a High Court judge in a costs ruling in the Irish Cement case. The matter had been reported in The Irish Times and it was put to her that this might have been relevant to peopleâs view of Hayes.
OâDonovan said she didnât read The Irish Times but she disagreed, saying that was just one issue and Irish Cement was important to people.
She gave evidence that she received details of the Brian Leddin CompaĂąeros WhatsApp group from someone other than Mulvihill in or around March 2021 â from whom, however, she didnât specify. She was âreally distressedâ by its contents, the jury heard.
When journalists contacted her, she said she was happy to speak about the messages as a matter of public interest. She said it showed the hidden sexist attitudes towards people in public life. By then, it had been widely spoken about online.
OâDonovan said she instructed Dr Breda Hayes to bring defamation proceedings against Gilleece in 2021 over online comments posted by the communications advisor on Twitter. She said she had wanted Gilleece to stop writing about her. She subsequently dropped the case two years later. By this stage, she had changed law firms, on amicable terms with Hayes.
Asked if she thought Gilleece was a misogynist, she replied that based on what she had seen, the answer was âyesâ.
âLetâs wait to hear how the others feelâ
The jury heard that, like Mulvihill, OâDonovan was unaware that Gilleece had been the subject of a bullying claim by Hayes in the wake of the Punchâs Cross incident in July 2019.
In correspondence with Hayes at the time, Gilleece said she agreed with two other branch members that she was not in favour of An Taisce putting in an objection to the âfirst dedicated block of much-needed student accommodation close to Limerick city centreâ.
The email, read out to the jury, continued: âSince Brian [Leddin] and I activated the Limerick association we have always behaved as a group in a collegiate and respectful mannerâ. For this reason, and to ensure against the group being used in future âfor someoneâs personal agendas, we have always conducted the submission of observations as a collaborative process and when agreement is not possible we simply vote on the matterâ.
She added that Leddin had introduced Google Docs, which was very user-friendly, and that she would be happy to give Hayes a tutorial on it ahead of the next meeting. She ended the email by saying that while Paul, Darragh, and herself were against putting in a submission on Punchâs Cross, âyou are seemingly for it Michelle, so letâs wait to hear how the others feelâ.
Hayes had responded excessively by raising a bullying complaint, counsel for Gilleece suggested to OâDonovan.
Harty then read from an email Hayes sent in reply to Gilleece and another An Taisce member. In it, the solicitor took issue with the statement that An Taisce Limerick had always behaved in a collegial and respectful manner: âRegrettably, that has not been my experience and your latest email is evidence of this fact.â
As a new member of An Taisce Limerick since December 2018, Hayes said she reluctantly became acting chair due to the very unforeseen and sudden health issues of the former chair. She claimed she received âno assistanceâ from Gilleece in the Curragower House Appeal to An Bord PleanĂĄla and with regard to another site submission.
While she credited Gilleece with being âsomewhat involvedâ with the revival of An Taisce Limerick, the organisation needed to âmove to the next levelâ to re-establish itself as a âpotent and credible forceâ in environmental protection. Being a member was not seen generally in a positive light, the email stated. Hayes said it had been a âconsiderable disadvantageâ to her on a professional and personal level, particularly when media attention focused on her personally.
âHow is this collegial?â
The email disputed the assertion that submissions on planning matters were a collaborative process subject to a vote, asserting that she and another committee member had previously been excluded on submitting an observation around the GPO in Limerick âHow is this collegial? How is this democratic excluding other Committee members?â
The email said it was not surprising that An Taisce was unable to retain its current members in view of the âexclusionary, prejudicial, divisive and child-like behaviour of certain membersâ.
Hayes said from her professional experience, this type of exclusionary behaviour would be regarded by the courts as âconstituting overt bullyingâ. âIn this case, it would be very easy to prove as it is all in writing,â it continued.
The email said the next time the media requested an interview with the five An Taisce members who unilaterally made a decision that excluded the chair, Hayes would direct them to Gilleece and âno doubt you will be able to field off the hostile cross-examination I have had to contend with previouslyâ.
Asked to identify where Gilleece had bullied Hayes in her email, OâDonovan replied that when you are under âsustained sabotageâ you can become âhypersensitiveâ and that this was something she had experienced herself. She said she felt sorry for Hayes because An Taisce was going out of its way to sabotage her efforts to help her community.
It was put to her that Hayes had only been in An Taisce for seven months at this point. âWho is feeding you this narrative,â Harty asked, suggesting to OâDonovan that her âsabotageâ remarks were âpreposterousâ and that she was making her evidence up as she went along. OâDonovan replied that if someone wanted to get rid of you from an organisation, this is exactly how they would do it. She said she was not surprised Hayes left. âWhy would you stay in this toxic environment?â She said Hayesâ character had been âassassinatedâ online and that was why they were all in court.
After expert evidence from a social media analyst about online engagement with Gilleeceâs tweets, Hayesâs side wrapped its case.
On Thursday afternoon, the script flipped to Gilleece and her defence.
A bullying claim is cleared
The 42-year-old started by setting out her background and family. A mother of an 18-month-old son, she had been brought up by her father, who was an architect, and her mother, who was a teacher. She studied at UL as an undergraduate before doing a research masterâs in UCD.
Early roles included an internship in Limerick County Council and work with the Limerick Civil Trust. She became involved with Leddin in the reinvigoration of An Taisce Limerick in 2015. After an informal interview, she said the head office in Dublin gave them approval to form a committee.
While An Taisce gets public funding for certain initiatives, she said its advocacy work is unfunded.
She recalled only three members on the committee before Breda and Michelle Hayes joined the Limerick branch in 2018, when the main issue was the planned demolition of Curragower House.
She said relations were fine prior to Punchâs Cross: People would say âI noticed a planning noticeâ and there would be a discussion about it, putting forward the reasons for and against a submission.
The Punchâs Cross development, described as local to Hayes, was different from the very first email, she said. It wasnât couched as âhow will we approach thisâ, it was âI am making a submissionâ, the court was told. Nor were any reasons presented to the group by Hayes as to why An Taisce should put forward a planning submission, she said.
Asked by her own counsel about her intentions in sending an email to Hayes on July 14, 2019, she said she just wanted to âcoolâ things down as âit was getting pretty tenseâ.
Back-and-forth correspondence followed. There were charges of procedural double standards by Hayesâs side, because previously only some An Taisce members made a submission on the change of a façade to the general post office in Limerick. This was explained by Gilleece as a result of operating to a tight deadline.
Communications advisor Emma Gilleece.
She said they contacted An Taisce HQ in Dublin for guidance on how to proceed amid the tensions over Punchâs Cross. They were told to hold an AGM early to resolve matters. She said they tried to do that, but a letter from Dr Hayes stopped the AGM on threat of injunction.
A secretary from HQ came down to interview everyone. She said this resulted in the drafting of a code of conduct. A report found that there had been no evidence of bullying.
Asked about why she posted the first allegedly defamatory tweet about the Hayesâs being âexperts in bullying and threatsâ in 2020, Gilleece said she was angry that the two had been tweeting about An Taisce. She said the Hayeses had left the group on bad terms and she wanted to put the record straight.
The emails they had sent around Punchâs Cross were âjust so extreme and just so unnecessaryâ, the jury was told. She said they had referred to a personal relationship of hers in a group email, and she just felt bullied.
Her own posts, including allegations that the sisters had bullied their way onto the PPN and were âfake environmentalistsâ, stemmed from her belief that Environmental Trust Ireland had been set up with the Hayesesâ involvement to secure a PPN place and that it had not met the stringent membership requirements applied to other groups. She accepted in the witness box that she did not have the evidence to support this assertion.
She also said she believed the sisters had pressured an An Taisce facilitator to secure additional representation on the PPN, a claim that was denied. The Hayeses were presenting themselves as environmentalists when what they really wanted to do was to stop certain developments, she alleged in the witness box.
Under cross-examination by Lupton, Gilleece acknowledged that the sisters had achieved significant results in environmental law and that she had previously complimented them.
âIâm not a misogynistâ
When she was sued for the content of her first three tweets in 2021, she said she felt âreally scaredâ as she had no way of paying them any money. She said the first she heard of it was when her father called and told her a letter marked âurgentâ had arrived at the house. She was not living in Limerick at the time.
The fact her father had to read this letter was worse than what was said in it, the jury heard. She initially hoped the letter was just intended to scare her but then another letter arrived.
Proceedings were issued. She said she was terrified and didnât tweet anything for the rest of 2021 or 2022.
In the wake of the WhatsApp leaks to the press, she tweeted an admission that she had called two women attacking her friends a âbitchâ and another rude word in the private group chat.
âIâm not a misogynist,â she told the court. She said she had been brought up by a âfiercely strong intelligent womanâ and was the eldest of four daughters, âso it really hurts me to be cast as thatâ.
Asked why she believed Hayes and OâDonovan were responsible for getting messages from the WhatsApp group published in the paper, she replied it was âjust from the way it was presentedâ. OâDonovan had done a photoshoot and Hayes was referred to in the article as a âprofessional womanâ.
She said she was contacted by three journalists, the third of whom published the piece in The Irish Mail on Sunday.
The student accommodation proposal at Punchâs Cross.
Gilleece said the effect of the defamation proceedings was terrifying. Her work was impinged. One contract was not renewed during this period, the jury heard. As a communications manager, she said she is supposed to come into meetings âreally bubblyâ but she felt like she was living a double life. âI wasnât really there.â
Her big mistake, she told the jury, was not backing the objection to Punchâs Cross. She said she wished she had just agreed with it and ânone of this would have happenedâ.
When the second set of proceedings were lodged by Hayes in 2023, she got an email from The Phoenix magazine to inform her they were running a story on the case. She was alone in Dublin airport and rang them straight away in a âknee-jerkâ reaction.
She told them she was a ânobodyâ. She said she would never forget the journalistâs reply: If the case was being brought in the High Court, then she must be somebody. The jury heard her photo was taken from Instagram and slapped on the front cover under the headline âEmma Gilleeceâs legal spatsâ. It was on newsstands for two weeks.
âWorld War III broke outâ
Gilleece said she had her first miscarriage in November 2023.
The following January she was out having tea with friends when the editor of RTĂ Culture rang her about a letter that had arrived into the legal department from Hayes Solicitors Limerick.
She said she started crying in the hotel lobby. âHe was really good. He said âI backed you Emmaâ.â
She had a second miscarriage that year.
In September 2024, she was contacted by An Garda SĂochĂĄna to inform her a complaint had been made against her. She was in her second trimester of pregnancy. She said she was in a mess on the phone saying, âIf I lose this baby, I donât know what Iâll doâ. The jury heard the guard wouldnât let her off the phone until someone was with me, and that fortunately her partner came home. The jury heard the complaint is still with the Director of Public Prosecutions.
Under cross-examination by Lupton, it was put to Gilleece that she is an author with a public profile, who has written for periodicals, and appeared on RTĂ and therefore was somebody who knows the power of words and how they can damage and hurt people.
He said she had made allegations on X without evidence about his client selling stories to newspapers. She had claimed the 2021 defamation proceedings were intended to gag her, but they had done nothing of the sort, he suggested. She had continued to post online.
Gilleece replied that she began reposting after a lengthy hiatus in 2021 and 2022 because she âreally regrettedâ being quiet while her friend Brian Leddin was being criticised.
Of the later tweets in 2023, Lupton honed in on a tweet alleging Hayes had abused her skills as a solicitor. He said that was a particularly damaging and serious thing to say about a solicitor with a professional reputation in Limerick.
Gilleece replied âI knowâ but added the caveat â âif they have a good professional reputationâ.
This was an answer she fell back on more than once in her interrogation. At one point she said: âThere are bad solicitors out there like bad doctors and architectsâ.
She denied that Hayesâs reputation had been eroded because of her.
Gilleece stood over her claim that the sisters were fake environmentalists, alleging that they pursued cases from which they could financially benefit.
She also denied that publishing on X part of a legal letter Hayes Solicitors had sent to her was âdog whistlingâ. The jury heard she wanted people to see it themselves, and decide whether there was overreach.
When Lupton said: âYou understand this was all done by youâ, the witness replied sarcastically that âyesâ, she had sent herself the legal letters.
Gilleece told the jury she had wanted an apology from Hayes in the wake of the An Taisce bullying claims that were not upheld. But this hadnât happened.
She said she had taken down some tweets on her solicitorâs advice, but left others up because she regarded them as her opinions. She said she had offered to mediate three times and would have apologised to Hayes if the first legal letter had sought only an apology but she understood it also sought financial compensation.
For a period of time prior to the court hearing, the jury heard she had represented herself as she could no longer afford lawyers.
âWorld War III broke outâ because she didnât want to object to Punchâs Cross, her personal life was brought into an An Taisce email thread and a year later Leddinâs political career was âruinedâ because he called the women he had a sexual relationship with âunhingedâ, she said.
After four days, the evidence was complete.
A matter of costs and damages
By the time the jury returned to court following the bank holiday weekend, the case had been whittled down by the lawyers to just five allegedly defamatory tweets on the issue paper.
Counsel took turns giving closing addresses to the jury. Harty, for Gilleece, went first. Apart from expert testimony, the jury had heard from only four witnesses, he said. Three had come to tell a story and one had come to tell the truth.
He criticised Hayesâs performance in the witness box. He said she gave a long speech to any question that didnât help her case and âavoided giving anything extra to the point of being comicalâ.
In the two early tweets, he said the jury had to assess the defence of honest opinion on a matter of public interest. Counsel argued that Gilleeceâs opinion that they were âexperts in bullying and threatsâ was based on true facts. âYouâve heard the manner in which they behaved when they didnât get their way,â he said. âBoth of them.â
He suggested that in everything they do, it is structured so that Breda Hayes gets the costs and Michelle Hayes gets the damages.
Harty said that Gilleece may have conceded too much in her evidence but he maintained she had told the truth and âhopefully the jury will value thatâ.
As someone who had sat on a committee with them, he said Gilleece had given evidence on why she believed the sisters were toxic. They pursued environmental causes as a way of drumming up business for Hayes Solicitors, it was alleged.
In relation to the later tweets Gilleece posted about an âorchestratedâ campaign against her and an abuse of legal skills, counsel questioned whether these had really done damage to Hayesâs reputation, when separately she had been criticised by a High Court judge.
He said Hayes had come to court to âtormentâ and âbullyâ Gilleece, asking for double her annual salary in damages.
âSmears and untruthsâ
In his closing address, Lupton asked the jury to put themselves in the shoes of Michelle Hayes, a solicitor and environmentalist who has had significant successes in her career. Gilleeceâs slurs had followed her around like a âbad smellâ and had led to disparagement of her reputation locally in Limerick.
He said the sideshow of the An Taisce WhatsApp group let the jury see the appalling behaviour going on behind closed doors.
Gilleece had openly referred to herself as an agitator in her online profile. Counsel said she appeared to be quite good at it and ran anonymous social media accounts.
He said a âcampaign of whispersâ, âsmears and untruthsâ over something that went on in an An Taisce meeting in 2019 had âtsunami-likeâ overspill.
Lupton said it was âoutrageousâ to say the Hayeses were here to get damages and costs. His client came to court because her reputation was tarnished, he submitted. Every tweet was a direct hit to her reputation that she has had to live with for six years, the jury was told.
Gilleece portrayed herself as the victim when she is âabsolutely notâ, he said. âIf you are going to pillory someone, what do you expect?â counsel argued.
Nor was it Gilleeceâs first rodeo. Elisa OâDonovan also had to sue Gilleece to get her to stop âdesktop trollingâ, it was submitted.
Counsel said the law presumes every citizen in Ireland has a good name and an undamaged reputation. The jury was asked to cast a cold eye about what was said about Hayes.
Solicitors are held to a very high standard to maintain the reputation of the whole profession, the court heard. They trade on their reputation and skill. Demeaning it is âhighly problematicâ, counsel said.
After a charge by the judge on how to approach its task, the jury retired on Tuesday evening with a series of questions to consider, spread over two issue papers. It didnât take long.
Five questions, one answer
The members returned just after lunch on Wednesday, having deliberated for just over two and a half hours. They returned unanimous answers to the five main questions.
Did a tweet posted by Gilleece on June 26, 2020 mean that Hayes had engaged in bullying and threats in the conduct of her business and professional affairs? The answer was no.
Did a post on December 24, 2020 mean Hayes was a âtoxic fake environmentalistâ? Again, the jury answered no.
They also rejected that a tweet from August 28, 2022 meant Hayes wrongfully used litigation to cause Gilleece to be in fear of speaking and to prevent her speaking.
The answer was also no to the claim that a tweet from April 1, 2024 meant Hayes abused her position as a solicitor and acted unethically. Lastly, the jury rejected that another tweet on the same date meant that Hayes had made contact with a newspaper to persuade them of a false and distorted narrative and to generate publicity unfavourable to Gilleeece.
Justice Quinn discharged the jury members and thanked them for their service.
As the verdict was handed down, Hayes, on one side of the court, lifted a hand to her mouth.
Gilleece, on the other side, stared ahead. For a moment, no sign of relief registered. Then, while being comforted, she broke down in tears.
The case was put back to November 17 for the legal teams to deal with ancillary matters.
Isnât that some load of nonsense to be going to the High Court with?
Bullet points please
Limerick politics is box office.
I asked Co-Pilot
-
The dispute began within An Taisce Limerick, where solicitor and environmental campaigner Michelle Hayes clashed with communications adviser Emma Gilleece and others over planning and environmental issues, particularly the proposed Punchâs Cross student development.
-
A leaked WhatsApp group intensified the controversy. Architect Marcus Mulvihill shared screenshots from an An Taisce-linked group that they considered toxic and said was being used to target or disparage people around Limerick.
-
The leak also exposed comments by former Green Party TD Brian Leddin, including remarks about former partner and Social Democrats councillor Elisa OâDonovan that became a major political controversy in 2021.
-
Hayes sued Gilleece for defamation, alleging that 26 posts on X between 2020 and 2024 damaged Hayesâs reputation as a solicitor and environmental campaigner.
-
The disputed posts contained serious allegations, including suggestions that Hayes was involved in bullying and threats, was a âfakeâ or âtoxicâ environmentalist, misused litigation, behaved unethically as a solicitor and helped promote a distorted story to the media.
-
Hayes said the posts caused significant personal and professional harm, including isolation from colleagues and damage to a reputation that Hayes regarded as crucial to working as a solicitor.
-
Gilleece denied malicious defamation and relied partly on honest opinion. Gilleece said the comments arose from genuine disputes within An Taisce and from a belief that Hayes and Hayesâs sister had behaved aggressively during those disagreements.
-
A major issue at trial was the 2019 bullying dispute. Hayes viewed conduct within An Taisce as exclusionary and bullying, while Gilleece disputed that account. An earlier An Taisce process had found no evidence of bullying.
-
After six days of High Court evidence, the case narrowed substantially, leaving the jury to decide whether five particular tweets carried the defamatory meanings alleged by Hayes.
-
The jury unanimously rejected all five claims. After deliberating for roughly two and a half hours, the jury found that the tweets did not mean what Hayes alleged they meant, bringing the central defamation case to a conclusion in Gilleeceâs favour.
This extreme preciousness of the @Limerix would come as no shock to TFK alumni
Can we get the bullet points bullet pointed?
What a dose
Daughter of the famous Tom McGarry.
No All Ireland hurling medals mind, but a great all rounder.
Ah, I see you know Pa.
Whatâs he at these days?
Retired from all sports I presume?
Granddaughter i would have thought? Sad to see either way
No idea. Knew him as a younger man⌠Iâd say heâs finished alright unless heâs playing lower league soccer which i doubt. Heâs around 44/45 now Iâd say
Actually the last time i saw him both of us were up in court. He had jumped on a bus and drove it a hundred yards down the road on Henry st of all places. Think Claughan had won a big match and he had a few pints on board. The whole court house got a good laugh off it.
No, sheâs a daughter alright.
Probably one of the youngest.
One of them is living in Drom.
I vaguely remember that alright. ![]()
![]()
![]()
Do you know the family?
Not them all. Just out this side. A few of the grandchildren played with Na Piarsaigh. JJ Carey who played full forward last Sunday is a grandson of Tom.
Sure Pa was always in the ânewsâ.
The real victims in this is the student accommodation didnt go ahead due to a bunch of NIMBY headbangers. Limerick politics is box office for self serving busy bodies