Munster Senior Hurling Championship 2023 (Part 1)

Barry Heffernan will be there too hopefully and Forde will still be starting.

Its not even a young team when you look at it.

You could interchange a few of your subs there and it would be much of a muchness.

Last year was easier to accept as the whole thing was a shit show from the start but this year everyone committed and got fit and yet it still turned to shit.

JF is an excellent hurler, as everyone recognizes, but not an excellent competitor when it counts. I doubt he will change at 30 going 31.

BH should be in the mix, alright.

2 Likes

Tipp’s quality reflects how shite the club championship has been the last few years.

Yesterday was my first time seeing Tipperary in the Championship this year. I didn’t see any of their 3 games in the mini blitz that were hidden behind the paywall and I was out the afternoon they played Limerick. I couldn’t believe how bad they were last night. They had that same dead on their feet, overtrained look that Waterford had last year. Granted the talent pool and supply lines are shallow at the moment but Cahill is not the managerial Messiah that plenty seem to think he is.

1 Like

You haven’t missed much.

The Munster Hurling Round Robin blitz generated a lot of hype but the quality was very poor. The fact Tipp stumbled their way through it speaks volumes.

Cahill has some good attributes as a manager but he wouldn’t have ‘it’ like Sheedy does. You get the sense that the players dont really know where they stand with him. You’d hear some great anecdotes about how he can flip over little things. One player turning up wearing pink shorts to training being a classic of this genre.

2 Likes

Bring back Bonnar

At the time, I would have said that Morris, Cahill & Ormond were the three best forwards on that team. And Seymour was some goalscorer.

I was surprised Ormond never made it.

You’d have to feel for Tipperary - they are at least a half decade away from competing for all irelands

Things have to get worse before they get better.

They are still in recovery since Kyle Hayes ran the length of the field

3 Likes

Only 6 seasons left in this decade. Pressure is mounting.

Given the diminishing returns over time from Cahill in Waterford it doesn’t look great for Tipp. Another pandemic might be their best bet.

1 Like

Its been well flagged in Tipp that that Under 20 championship in 2019 was the worst underage competition of all time.

Tipp won it pulling up scoring seven (7) goals against some poor misfortunes from Wexford in the Semi Final and had around 4 goals scored after 5 minutes in the Final

1 Like

Tipperary have generally had a knack of getting one on the board early in a decade to get that particular monkey off their back - 1950, 1961, 1971, 1991, 2001, 2010.

The 1980’s was an outlier in that regard, only getting there in the last chance saloon in 1989. They were coming from about 1984 onwards though with a conveyor belt of talent and after 1987 it was only around the corner. Can’t see them winning one anytime soon in this decade as things stand at the moment.

1 Like

Had Limerick many over 30 starting for the Munster final?

Quaid, hannon, mulcahy, Morrissey, Reidy 30 and older.

Byrnes, hegarty, O’Donoghue all 29 this year.

Donovan, m Casey, r English 28 this year.

Is Richie only 28? Thought he was older

Alan Tynan isn’t related to a hurler watching him yesterday. He’s strong and athletic but stone cold useless. A Dublin hurler. You’d wonder where are the stick men you’d begrudgingly associate with Tipp?

1 Like

He is pretty much the sole example of a fella coming back from full-time rugby and being any use. But even before that he wasn’t anyone’s idea of a stickman

Seamus Kennedy at wing forward was a strange move.ronan Maher has been played in every position in the backs this championship.starting Callanan was a bad move.dont think anybody expected he would be a starter this year.dont think Cathal Barrett was 100% fit to start.only positive is Rhys Shelly looks to be the find of the championship.

I thought Kennedy was one of their better players in fairness.

Jerome Cahill has been the most obvious loss, himself and Morris the best of that team.

Ormonde has been very injury prone and not helped by playing with a club that play 2 sweepers.

Seymour is probably as good as Conor Bowe but is very tempestuous.

A big problem with Cahill ball is Tipp don’t have the athletes when Stakelum/Tynan are not on top. They are not there on the club scene either.

Forde is probably my biggest disappointment of the whole thing. I actually think they should put him at 6 or 7 next year at this stage, he’s not going to cut the mustard next year at 31 with his back facing goal.

1 Like