Rugby World Cup 2023/ Crochet & Knitting chit chat

The statement is pretty clear there. At the height of the GGA Championship nobody cared in Ulster and they switched over to rugby Test matches (ones regularly lampooned on here).

That kind of engagement will pay off in time. Those with a partitionist mindset will say having only a couple of Ulster players involved is an issue but it really isnā€™t.

Its only fair @Halfpipe explain it to you himself rather than having you try to dissect it further as Iā€™m not sure from what youā€™re saying that you really are getting to the nuts of the nuance.

They are too often too marginal for me to do that.

Great to see you keeping up with events in the Ulster championship @Tim_Riggins, just shows the reach of the competition! While my own anecdotes certainly do carry substantial weight and I can understand why you place such value on them, probably best not to assess the strength of various sports up here solely on the tv setting in a pub in a unionist town 2 years ago.

6 Likes

I donā€™t know where this narrative is coming from but itā€™s nonsense . Barnes basically said sorry I didnā€™t see the replay but from where I was it was a foul . That now seems to have turned into Barnes apologising for giving the penalty which he never did .

3 Likes

Myself and @Little_Lord_Fauntleroy keep abreast of all tv developments regarding sports in Ireland and also the GGA. Naturally this caught my eye.

The last line is cute- come back again here reloaded before trying this craic again.

1 Like

3 mins is nothing. Itā€™s basically one more run of play.

Iā€™d also look at varying the reward for a drop goal vs. a penalty.

It shouldnā€™t have been given a penalty in the first place. The other stuff is added from what Iā€™ve read of the situation since.

2 Likes

Youā€™re actually increasing the vagaries of refereeing. They should be reduced.

This one looks like a red tbh
https://twitter.com/DMAC_1O/status/1718747264838144461?t=cSVsgU1HqTLizZLxCBOq5A&s=19

Was a poor call in my eyes but thereā€™s split seconds in the judgement. Can see how the mix up on him appearing to apologise was made.

I actually think Barnes will be a loss. If world rugby had any initiative, theyā€™d send him down to the Antipodes and get him involved in getting their refs down there on the same page and level. Thought SH refs were all over the shop in comparison to NH counterparts this tournament.

Barnes leaving on top while best of the lot. Never thought Iā€™d say that after his first few forays reffing Munster.

2 Likes

Itā€™s all very strange to a rugby outsider . In other sports youā€™d call the refereeing inconsistent. But in rugby itā€™s just the rules are open to ā€˜interpretationā€™ and you have to ā€˜paint a pictureā€™
Which is bizarre in extreme, itā€™s like tricking the ref into believing something. The South American soccer players get absolutely hammered for doing that .

1 Like

Following your footballing example through, youā€™d say VAR has really cleared things up, it has? And what need was there for VAR if there was full certainty in ref decisions?

Uncertainty and debate over decisions exists in all team sports really

Tom Oā€™Toole is from Ratoath.

1 Like

Iā€™d say there was serious competition for those rights

5 Likes

Probably decent interest. First major rugby rights deal for Sky in a while.

Big push in the U.K. to put Six Nations on the protected list.

1 Like

Are they not always on sky?

There was ā€œprobablyā€ decent interest, by all accounts, but we are none the wiser as to who these other vested parties may have been.