Smoking Ban - In Cars?

A BAN on smoking in cars is being considered by the Government, Minister for Health Dr James Reilly has said.

Dr Reilly, who advocated such a radical measure while in opposition, said a potential ban was being considered in the context of the tobacco policy review taking place.

In a response to a parliamentary question from Fianna Fáil TD Seán Fleming as to whether he would consider banning smoking in cars where children under 16 were present, Dr Reilly said he was “in favour of legislating in this area” but added the public would need persuading first.

The Welsh assembly is considering banning smoking in cars where children are present within three years unless motorists change their behaviour.

A Department of Health spokeswoman said officials were examining two scenarios here. One involved a ban on smoking where children under 16 were present. The other involved a blanket ban on smoking in private cars if it was deemed that a limited prohibition involving children was unworkable.

This could make Ireland the first country to impose such a ban. Smoking in taxis, company cars and vans, which are classed as workplaces, is already prohibited.

Dr Reilly said the extent of smoking in cars needed to be assessed and followed by a campaign to persuade the public a ban was necessary. He said breaching the ban would be considered as either a road traffic offence or public health issue.

He believed the workplace smoking ban, introduced in 2004, was a success because it was underpinned by a clear “evidence-base, good planning, the mobilisation of public opinion by way of a public education and information campaign, and simple, clear and enforceable legislation”.
Such a ban would have the support of anti-tobacco lobby Ash, which has been pressing for it for years, and by Senator John Crown.

“It is the commonplace experience of every citizen who drives through the city and who gets stuck in a line of traffic to see children strapped into car seats in an enclosed car with one or more adults smoking in that car,” said Mr Crown in the Seanad a few weeks ago.

Earlier this month, the Welsh assembly said it wanted to make Wales the first country to introduce a ban on smoking in cars containing children.

The Welsh first minister, Carwyn Jones, said such a move would be a “powerful statement of intent about our commitment to the health of our children”.

Anti-tobacco campaigner Prof Luke Clancy of Ash said experience had shown voluntary compliance and partial bans did not work. He urged the Welsh government to simply go ahead and impose a ban.

It’s a smoke screen (if you excuse the pun), conveniently released the same day as the property tax. The smoking “ban” got more coverage on the front pages this morning than the home owners tax.

You’re probably right. They had to think of something that would light up the front pages as opposed to the dour news on the property tax.

If there’s one thing people hate more than a TAX it’s a BAN

It’s no major deal though I’d say.

:angry: Fucking cunts,wont be able to have a wank legally next!!!

The government have ways of filtering what gets into the media and this is one of them.

You can’t legally do it on the bus

This would be very difficult to police. How are they going to prevent people smoking in their cars? Have guards stopping cars and doing a sniff test in the window to see is a driver has been smoking! I don’t see how it’s practical to implement. As suggested above, more of a diversion from the property tax announcement.

:unsure: Oooops!!

Go way you.

Should be easy enough to police, no different than the mobile ban really.

I can see this being a real drag and a pain in the butt for drivers

It’s a serious point.

The council lads must be getting jealous of someone else tarring the roads for them. :slight_smile: :ph34r:

Correct. An unimportant story that’s a small bit media and just the right amount controversial.

:lol:

Most things that are in the media are unimportant.

I think TFK should issue a press release denouncing this as a non-story.

How do people find out about the important things so? seems like a bit of a ‘tree falling the forest’ scenario