The Official 2012 Club Championship Thread

[Mullach_Ide]

[quote=“Kinvara’s Passion, post: 749454, member: 686”]listen scan

A guy hit me in the exact same way back in the 2005 galway champ. 3 operations and many physio sessions later I have no more than 60% movement in my arm.

Its a dangerous stroke, deserved a red… end of.[/quote]
Listen scan, that wouldn’t be a red card in an intercounty game, full shtop.

[Mullach_Ide]

@Bandage

But KK draw every last ounce out of themselves and play a hard tackling, high intensity game. Those saying Thomas’s didn’t play well but still won may technically be correct but they aren’t acknowledging the workrate and application of KK. They’re not like the Offaly teams of old in terms of being full of swagger and style and that’s why their man attacker Currams was so sorely missed. They play with aggression but I don’t think they’re a dirty side and Thomas’s actually did very well to maintain their composure when they went two points behind to come through at the end.

Spot on m8. Johnny Giles would love their honesty of endeavour.

[KinvarasPassion]

@Mullach Ide

Listen scan, that wouldn’t be a red card in an intercounty game, full shtop.

Wouldn’t or Shouldn’t?

[myboyblue]

@count of monte cristo

im still in shock, all ireland qtr final…fuck me…

You’ll see one again someday mate, don’t worry.

[myboyblue]

[quote=“Kinvara’s Passion, post: 749454, member: 686”]listen scan

A guy hit me in the exact same way back in the 2005 galway champ. 3 operations and many physio sessions later I have no more than 60% movement in my arm.

Its a dangerous stroke, deserved a red… end of.[/quote]
You must be as soft as puke. It was a harmless clatter.

@count of monte cristo

im still in shock, all ireland qtr final…fuck me…

You’ll see one again someday mate, don’t worry.

[Appendage]

@myboyblue

It’s a mans game. It was a mere clip. Your anger and ire is misdirected and unfounded. Laois put Galway football in its box yesterday thats all you need to know.

A clip with the hurl is a sending off. End off. It was stupid, pointless and deserved it’s red.

It should be a reevery time it happens but as one of the intelligent posters notes it isn’t generally applied in inter county games.

Fior gaels can fuck off. I trust my own eyes and don’t need twitter to form my opinion.

[myboyblue]

[quote=“Appendage, post: 749474, member: 11”]A clip with the hurl is a sending off. End off. It was stupid, pointless and deserved it’s red.

It should be a reevery time it happens but as one of the intelligent posters notes it isn’t generally applied in inter county games.

Fior gaels can fuck off. I trust my own eyes and don’t need twitter to form my opinion.[/quote]
Nor do I, it only confirms my opinion to be correct.

I would fear for hurling if little slips like that are to be considered sendings off.

[Appendage]

[quote=“myboyblue, post: 749477, member: 180”]Nor do I, it only confirms my opinion to be correct.

I would fear for hurling if little slips like that are to be considered sendings off.[/quote]

You are wrong. He stuck him deliberately, it wasn’t a slip.

[Mullach_Ide]

@Kinvara's Passion

Wouldn’t or Shouldn’t?

Wouldn’t.

[myboyblue]

I’m quite happy with my assessment pf this incident and this referee. Regardless Thomas’ are worthy winners and well done to them. The Wests Awake.

[Appendage]

@myboyblue

I’m quite happy with my assessment pf this incident and this referee. Regardless Thomas’ are worthy winners and well done to them. The Wests Awake.

Happy and wrong.

[myboyblue]

@Appendage

Happy and wrong.

If this is wrong, I’d rather not be right. In fact Hurling will be the poorer for my being wrong.

[count_of_monte_crist]

[quote=“myboyblue, post: 749467, member: 180”]You must be as soft as puke. It was a harmless clatter.

You’ll see one again someday mate, don’t worry.[/quote]

Shouldn’t be too hard there’s 6 on every year.

[Appendage]

@myboyblue

If this is wrong, I’d rather not be right. In fact Hurling will be the poorer for my being wrong.

So hurling would be poorer for the punishment of cowardly, pointless and dangerous slaps on player’s hands/elbows as they’re running by?

Why not just eliminate from the game? It’s nasty and in fairness to Sexton he’s consistently sent people off for it.

[count_of_monte_crist]

[quote=“Appendage, post: 749505, member: 11”]So hurling would be poorer for the punishment of cowardly, pointless and dangerous slaps on player’s hands/elbows as they’re running by?

Why not just eliminate from the game? It’s nasty and in fairness to Sexton he’s consistently sent people off for it.[/quote]

I hate this shite of people justifying cowardly dirty strokes as it being a mans game, fuck off.

Anyone who’s played the game can tell the difference between a dirty stroke and a manly/fair stroke, perhaps this is where your failings lie Mbb.

many’s a person has come in from a game with broken fingers and to an extent wrists they can be justified by going for the ball, but breaking a lads elbow, no dont think so.

[myboyblue]

[quote=“Appendage, post: 749505, member: 11”]So hurling would be poorer for the punishment of cowardly, pointless and dangerous slaps on player’s hands/elbows as they’re running by?

Why not just eliminate from the game? It’s nasty and in fairness to Sexton he’s consistently sent people off for it.[/quote]
Why not eliminate all physicality from the game, we’d have great free scoring games, imagine the scores that’d be racked up? We’d have a great product. You, the Count and the Galway fella might be onto something here. It could also spell the end of physcal sides such as Kilkenny as strong powers in Hurling. There migh be something in this.

[maroonandwhite]

The only one on to something is the count. If you had ever actually played hurling you’d realise there’s nothing more cowardly than a getting hit in an unprotected hand or arm while your playing the ball. You think getting this kind of belt off a pussy who’s afraid to meet you head on makes someone soft. Clueless. And 24 hours after pretending your from Offaly your now vicariously speaking as a Kilkenny supporter! Have you no pride these counties are supposed to be your rivals. Galway did better against Kilkenny when the games got physical last year, Donnellans sending off killed us in the replay. So your wrong on all counts.

[myboyblue]

This m&w fella is a howl

[anon61956325]

@maroonandwhite

The only one on to something is the count. If you had ever actually played hurling you’d realise there’s nothing more cowardly than a getting hit in an unprotected hand or arm while your playing the ball. You think getting this kind of belt off a pussy who’s afraid to meet you head on makes someone soft. Clueless. And 24 hours after pretending your from Offaly your now vicariously speaking as a Kilkenny supporter! Have you no pride these counties are supposed to be your rivals. Galway did better against Kilkenny when the games got physical last year, Donnellans sending off killed us in the replay. So your wrong on all counts.

+1

Well said mate.

[maroonandwhite]

@myboyblue

This m&w fella is a howl

And your a coward who never played hurling and hates where he’s from while perversely and pathetically celebrating that kip getting to all Ireland quarter finals as a major achievement. I think all of the above has been clearly established.