Unpopular opinions or views you hold

The Easter Rising volunteers were mostly a bunch of lunatics (socialists, dreamers, republicans) who have been held up as patriots and heroes, rather than the deranged zealots that they were. Holing themselves up in a buildings like GPO, Bolands Millsā€¦.sending poorly equipped young volunteers to their slaughter.

They were widely condemned and derided at the time for the carnage and civilian deaths, which numbered 374 (38 of whom were children). If it wasnā€™t for a twist of fate whereby the British executed the rebels instead of incarcerating them, they would be but a footnote in history.

History is written by the victors and it has looked kindly upon these. Pearse knew the folly but felt the sacrifice necessary under the circumstances. Thereā€™s truth in what you say but as in most historical conflicts itā€™s not quite that simple.

@Malarkey and @Fagan_ODowd ā€¦would yis rate Burial ahead of Van?

I might step in here if you donā€™t mind. Yes. Yes I would.

1 Like

Iā€™d largely prefer Burial.

Moondance is a very good record

Van Morrison greatest hits are good but his back catalogue is 75% dull

1 Like

What kind of people do you think are usually revolutionaries?

17 Likes

:clap::clap::slightly_smiling_face::slightly_smiling_face:

1 Like

Well youā€™re in the right thread. Lads slagging off astral weeks likeā€¦pure Palestines. Itā€™s just one of those miraculous occurrences- a serendipitous congruence of place, time and talent- luke miles davis running into john coltrane, adderly, kelly etc when recording ā€˜kind of blueā€™, or the lad ending up playing organ in ā€˜tangled up in blueā€™. Its hard to believe a grumpy wee east belfast carbuncle like morrison could be so inspired, original and godlike. Thereā€™s a van morrison at every bookies, bus stop and bar on the Newtownards Roadā€¦its incredible that astral weeks ever happened. Its like he just discovered it, or that the muse meant to give it to someone else.

Theyā€™re well named. Iā€™ll give them that.

You could just listen to the band ā€˜Burialā€™ instead

Van Morrison is an exceptionally talented songwriter. Heā€™s just a grumpy selfish fucker who can suck the life out of a room when he decides to.
Paul Brady and Christy Moore are baby versions.

1 Like

Aw. Dont be like that.

Thatā€™s 3 replies now.

Coney Island is a great aul track

2 Likes

Bright side of the road was wan of our two wedding dance tracks.

Obviously you hadnā€™t discovered Burial

The unappreciated scholars who shit on the people who know less than you :joy::joy:

Great movie.

3 Likes

Youā€™re welcome