The professionalism and size of Dublin means a lot of counties just can’t compete that’s a given. But the likes of Meath, Kildare, Galway and especially Cork have the populations and resources to do the same. Places like Kerry & Mayo where football is king the same. I know half the county is gone for them but Antrim Down and Derry’s return of late is a disgrace really.
I think their biggest advantage is their players all live at home during college allowing them to live more disciplined lives.
The likes of Con O’Callaghan wouldn’t have been sitting on a couch eating pizza and drinking cans at 3 o’clock on a Tuesday in November, unlike Tyrone lads above in UUJ or Kerry lads below in UCC.
The Dublin lads seem to make rapid progress from 19-22 unlike other counties, whose players go backwards during this time.
The other counties aren’t. Most of their development funding (ie GPOs) is paid directly via provincial councils and hadn’t been accounted for in Johns figures as he’s replicating what Ewans PhD student and others have erroneously said in the past. The breakdown of that funding per county is not available so it’s difficult to confirm what exactly they get for development funding,
Dublin’s GPO funding is channeled through their own board. They get a tiny piece of the Leinster council development funding also.,
I think a huge factor of Dublin lads improving between 18-21 is the standard of the county league at Div 1 and Div 2 as well as the county championship. They get at least 15 top quality games per year and improve accordingly.
Dublin have only won 5 of the last 16 Leinster Minor Championships, 10 of the last 16 Leinster Under 21/20 Championships and 15 of the last 16 Leinster Senior Championships.
In Club, you’d say the town teams dominate underage and it levels off at Senior, but the opposite is happening with Dublin.
I’m on the other side of the argument to you on balance but I’ve yet to see a good explanation for this from ewan and the gang. If anything the finances etc should have more of an impact at underage