That devastating first half showed how mad it is to fantasise that a return to some kind of Jack Charlton tactics could be effective in today’s international football. Sure, there’s always the slim hope you’ll force a defender into a mistake, but it’s much more likely that you get piggy-in-the-middled. This is why Stephen Kenny believed Ireland had to become a side who knew how to play with the ball.
Put ‘em under pressure football still exists, but now it looks like what Atalanta did to Bayer Leverkusen in the Europa League final last May. The Italian team pressed man to man all over the pitch. When any Leverkusen player was on the ball there was an Atalanta player hunting him down. Whoever he might pass to would have another Atalanta player hunting him down.
Matching up man to man all over the pitch obviously meant that Atalanta were playing one on one at the back. This defied the conventional wisdom that you should aim to have one more defender than the opposition has attackers. Atalanta accepted that risk as a price worth paying for the ability to enforce their pressure game further up the pitch.
Compare this to what Ireland were trying to do on Saturday. We played a back five, including three centre backs who, most of the time, had nobody to mark. This meant that England had at least two and often three spare players in midfield. They played around the outnumbered Irish midfielders like they were training cones.
Yet the supposed increased defensive solidity brought by the extra defenders was illusory. Trent Alexander-Arnold played a 50-yard pass right through Ireland’s centre for the first goal. “Should never happen, at any level,” said Hallgrímsson.
Greece will be a proper test of where we are. They played through us like we weren’t there under Spock (I’d say they could have gone another 90 mins again it was so easy). That was recently too. Hopefully we can improve on that
Ireland’s problem is they’ve been pulled from Jack to Billy and back to Jack tactics wise by different managers. The team must rightly disorientated. The new fella only met the players last Wednesday or whatever and the match on Saturday was pretty much a meet and greet for him rather than him being the actual manager.
Even if we have no central midfielders of note, you can’t just play 2 in there these days.
That 5-4-1/5-2-3 that Spock & Sheasy rolled out needs to be put out to pasture.
Kelleher
O’Shea, Collins, Omobamidele, Scales;
Ogbene, Knight, Smallbone, AN Other
Szmodics, Ferguson.
Sammie would need to drop into midfield & onto their holding player when we don’t have the ball to make it a three. Let’s see what he can do from a more central role, he’s been played off the left so far.
Dunno who could play on the left of midfield but it would need to be someone who can work up & down the flank. You couldn’t really get away with playing Parrott or someone, as that front 6 offers fuck all without the ball really.
Actually we’re a bit fucked irrespective of what way we line up tbh.
When did Robbie Brady last deliver a set-piece that made him worth his place? I dont think he was ever really a full-back anyway. I think we urgently need pace out there
I’d be inclined to play Ogbene and Idah up front. Greece play a high(ish) line against us the last time. Ogbene’s pace would keep them very honest and give Idah a foil. Smodiczczczsss behind, with a three in midfield all reasonably deep-lying, maybe even including Obomadamidele (no way I’ve spelled that correctly) as he looks good with the ball at his feet. Then a flat back four behind them. So a 4-3-1-2. Not a huge amount of width except for maybe the full-backs, but solid in the middle.
Coleman is such an admirable footballer but unfortunately you’re right that his time is probably up. He’ll be nearing 38 by the time the World Cup comes around in the US. Albeit maybe a 41 year old *Pepe’s performances in the Euros have given him an aspirational goal. It’s a pity Trap didn’t introduce him into the set-up sooner. He could’ve been starting for us by 2010/11 but barely made the squad for Euro 2012. If TFK is correct in its assumptions (which it generally is) then Doherty isn’t a suitable short-term replacement. Festy didn’t last long in Udinese. Sam Curtis appears to be a good prospect and it was encouraging to see him score for the U21’s against the Turks but I’d be wary of his mentality after hearing him in a podcast. He came across a bit of a “Big Time Charlie” which is very rare for ROI MNT players over the years. Hopefully Sheffield United’s relegation affords him more opportunity.
*Bar that near catastrophic slip for the huge Sesko chance against Slovenia.