Celtic Summer Transfer Window 2020 & Associated Malahide Public Amenities Discussion

Really? He’s in and out at Southampton. Would he go for more or less than they paid for him if they sold him now?

The key word is “relative “ . He has been a decent signing for Southampton and relatively good value .

1 Like

I don’t think Armstrong was that highly rated by Celtic fans so bit of a different situation

he was a bit part player in the SPL and is a star in the EPL

1 Like

Scored 5 goals from midfield in 30 appearances in the League for the Saints last season. Not bad going overall.

Sounds a bit like Roy Keane that time.

Relative to what?

got destroyed by an optican playing for clyde

2 Likes

He started 19. He is a bit part player.

Relative to poor signing and great signings over the years . He has been a decent enough signing .

Makes the 5 goals look very impressive so. Far batter stats than that Hojbjerg fella Spurs have signed. Albeit Armstrong is a more attack minded midfielder.

Hojberg is a holding midfielder. Armstrong plays off the striker or up in a three.

Hence I acknowledged he’s more attacking. Anyway my original point was that I think Edouard and indeed Dembele before him would be good additions for Premier League sides.

Because Armstrong played a few games for Southampton?

I remember reading somewhere that Edouard was in French underage teams ahead of Mbappe. Definitely has a bit about him. Dembele has since gone on to perform well in the Champions League with Lyon.

He got a start in a youth game ahead of mbappe. Jesus sign him up.

Dembele has never scored more than 20 league goals in a season. Is a bit of a sick note and isn’t a main stay in the Lyon team.

Playing in the SPL is in no way a barometer for doing well in a more competitive league

What has Tierney done?

You attempted to deconstruct his argument by focusing on one player. He also named Van Dyjk, Wanyama and a few more who have done well

Edouard is probably very good I’d say. Looks a really strong athlete with real pace who could play up on his own, a prerequisite these days.

The Liverpool left-back Robertson started up there as well.

Lot of very good players in the Scottish national team at the minute, we seem to be producing good young forwards now though.

McTominay
Gilmour (Chelsea) best scottish prospect in probably 30 years but injured now, achilles, disaster
John McGinn at Villa
Robertson and Tierney
McBurnie from Sheffield United, big lad up front

That’s a fairly decent 5 or 6 to build around. They should be qualifying for things.

1 Like

John Mcginn