Tipp fans will tell Kelly did it all on his own.
I try not to listen to Tipp fans.
Iām disappointed the corks fans arenāt backing their man.
Is he one of yours?
Once again the Limerick lads have shown themselves up to be the biggest simpletons on the forum.
Horgan was a serious player too. Savage pair of wrists and put up huge tallies while the windy fuckers around him went missing.
I just donāt think he was the ball-winner Kelly was
Kelly was a much better player, and thatās not an insult that is just a fact of life
1 Like
Yeah that makes sense ā¦ iām here arguing for Horgan and I then vote Kelly with my other alias . 
Kelly without a doubt. But Horgan is a great no doubt about it. It will be a travesty if he doesnāt win an All Ireland. His point against Clare in the dying moments of the 2013 All Ireland was worthy of any All Ireland match winning score but questionable timekeeping put paid to that.
2 Likes
Kelly was majestic from 2001-2006 or so. He had a great game in the 2009 All Ireland but by and large he was on a completely different level in the earlier years. I doubt any Tipp man who saw Tipp in the mid noughties would take any of the forwards of recent years ahead of him, the lack of help around him added to his stature among the Tipp supporters also. A great clubman too even still, much to my annoyance.
Horgan is a very good player but heās only really stepped up a level the last few years, most of his career he was a good free taker who could be stopped easily enough by a good corner back
Iām going to hang my poll hat up after this. I was hoping to create a healthy and positive debate.
Unless he can hang on for another 3 years minimum I canāt see him winning one. He could do mind, he looks a fella that looks after himself and heās not overly reliant on speed
Must try harder
Na Iām miserable after this one.
Youād think a few lads would be up to a bit of ball hopping and winding the Tip lads up but the Limerick lads fear Tipp and itās evident in the voting .
They all had a go, mate.
People hate me too much theyāll do anything to disagree with me.
Horgan settled this one ages ago
https://www.irishmirror.ie/sport/gaa/hurling/hurling-news/patrick-horgan-chasing-down-the-16262858
Limerick steamers.
Mate, when I looked in here and voted just after you put up the poll you had voted for Eoin Kelly 
4 Likes