Galway v Tipperary - All Ireland Senior Hurling Semi-Final 2017

They’re fighting each other in prison now in the chip camp.

That was my first thought too. Tipp, being the home of hurling, will hardly play a sweeper after all the hullabaloo the last few weeks.

1 Like

Will Galway name their team tonight?

Id imagine they will actually select as late as possible to give whelan every chance, but he won’t be anywhere near right.
It’d be a picklington level error to start him.
I doubt he will. Might be named as a ballhop.
Canning is defo fit though.

:thinking:

Joe Canning won’t stay Centre-Forward bud, Tipp will hardly tell Ronan Maher to follow him everywhere and leave the centre wide open.
I’m suggesting it is a possibility that Tipp might man mark Canning.
We don’t play with a sweeper cc @anon7035031

Some fellas haven’t a fucking clue what a sweeper does in hurling mate. They’d be as well of sticking to the NFL or EPL

I realize math isn’t a strong point in Tipp, but if you drop back a midfielder to mark a forward, how many defenders do you have? You can call the spare defender who plays in front of the full back line whatever you like, pal.

It’s for keeping the beating respectable by and large. Keeps a manager in place an extra season.

If Canning is man marked by a midfielder and Canning floats around the half/full forward line you will be playing 7 at the back. Galway will have 6 forwards. Is that not an atypical situation of a sweeper system?

Sad but true, after Tipperary dismantling the sweeper system with ease over the past few years.

No it’s fucking not, when Kilkenny were pulling Eoin Larkin back around Centre Field/ Half Back were they playing with a sweeper? Christ above no wonder Galway haven’t won an All Ireland since they stopped getting a bye into the semi-final.

2 Likes

If Ronan Maher drops back to protect the full back line and isn’t man marking anyone, how is that different to the role De Burca plays with Waterford? In that scenario is his job not to cut off the supply of ball to the Galway inside line and launch attacks, freed up from man marking duties?

The lengths the Tipp lads are going to here to deny the suggestion of playing a sweeper is comical.

Either that or they genuinely can’t grasp it.

You’re just talking shit for the sake of it now. De Burca practically plays in the full back line for Waterford.
The tactic of the Waterford Full Back line in the 2015 Munster Final was to allow the ball to break in behind them and for De Burca to sweep behind them.
Last year Tipp pushed right up on him, not allowing him the space to sweep behind the full back line.
I said he would play Maher Centre Back but deeper. Joe Canning will drift between Centre Field and Centre Forward, why would you have your Centre Back follow him and leave the entire centre open?

Lads, we shouldn’t be questioning their tactics. They are proven geniuses in that regard.

9 Likes

True Dat

4 Likes

Lads are the teams named tonight

Tipp team tomorrow night pal.

1 Like

Chronically busy week here, some decent hurling talk and sniping going on here, but a lot of filler. Canning wasn’t fit for the leinster final, couldn’t move freely at all, some brainless cunts here think they have him sussed from that game. He’s still not 100% now but will be better. If Conor Cooney moves out who would be better full?