Tony Kelly may become one of te greats but thatās a silly statement. In terms if consistent midfield play heās not even the best midfielder in Clare. Galvin is super at what he does and I would say understands the role better. Kelly fades too much to be considered the best midfielder. He is very easy on the eye, and his inspiration thru skillful moves is worth a lot but he has someway to go yet. He was snuffed out at half forward more than once this year so thatās an even less fair statement.
Tomas Waters 
Over the year Harnedy should have got a POTY nominee, ahead if Horgan I think. Consistency has to be rewarded.
It seems silly having 2 guys nominated for 2 awards. Surely it kinda defeats the purpose.
Not true. The great Ollie Walsh left in 6 in the 1963 Final and went home with a winners medal.
Mossy Waters transformation is complete, a pity he may never grace the game again
The Ollie Walsh precedent has already been alluded to on this thread a few hours back.
Simlpy not true. Shanahan won 4 or 5 balls in the first half that were put on a plate for him by a dominant half backline, McInerney won a heap of ball in both halves.
Canāt believe Mulcahy got a nomination, he the 3rd best player in our full forward line this year
It just goes to show that alot if these awards/nominations are based in reputation. Thereās a few other questionable ones in there too.
Zane Keenan was more worthy of an All Star nomination than Mulchahy, cunts :mad:
Who?
Iāve just noticed Shane OāDonnell got nominated :oops: 
Did Walter Walsh get nominated last year?
No, and rightly so.
Nominees 2012 GAA GPA Hurling All-Stars sponsored by Opel
Goalkeepers: Anthony Nash (Cork), Nickie Quaid (Limerick), James Skehill (Galway).
Full Backs: Paul Murphy (Kilkenny), JJ Delaney (Kilkenny), Johnny Coen (Galway), Fergal Moore (Galway), Jackie Tyrell (Kilkenny), Richie McCarthy (Limerick), Michael Cahill (Tipperary), Kevin Hynes (Galway), Shane OāNeill (Cork).
Half backs: Brian Hogan (Kilkenny), Brendan Bugler (Clare), Padraic Maher (Tipperary), David Collins (Galway), Michael Walsh (Waterford), Tony Ćg Regan (Galway), Tommy Walsh (Kilkenny), Niall Donoghue (Galway), Kieran Joyce (Kilkenny).
Midfielders: Andy Smith (Galway), Kevin Moran (Waterford), Stephen Molumphy (Waterford), Pa Cronin (Cork), Iarla Tannian (Galway), Michael Fennelly (Kilkenny).
Half Forwards: Henry Shefflin (Kilkenny), Cyril Donnellan (Galway), Niall Burke (Galway), Patrick Bonnar Maher (Tipperary), TJ Reid (Kilkenny), Pa Bourke (Tipperary), Damien Hayes (Galway), Danny Sutcliffe (Dublin), Richie Power (Kilkenny).
Full forwards: Eoin Larkin (Kilkenny), Joe Canning (Galway), Noel McGrath (Tipperary), Patrick Horgan (Cork), John Mullane (Waterford), Brian OāMeara (Tipperary), Richie Hogan (Kilkenny), John Conlon (Clare), David Burke (Galway).
The county by county breakdown is as follows: Galway (14), Kilkenny (12), Tipperary (6), Cork (4), Waterford (4), Limerick (2), Clare (2), Dublin (1).
The final team of 15 players will be announced live on RTĆ television on Friday October 26 at the GAA/GPA All-Stars Awards ceremony sponsored by Opel.
Nominations for Hurler of the Year
Henry Shefflin (Kilkenny)
Paul Murphy (Kilkenny)
Joe Canning (Galway)
Nominations for Young Hurler of the Year
Johnny Coen (Galway)
Niall Burke (Galway)
Danny Sutcliffe (Dublin)
Top scorer from play in the championship, why wouldnāt he be? Single handedly beat Wexford and Cork one could argue
Would have featured in every game bar the drawn final I believe. Starting in three and coming on as a sub in three. Scored goals in each game he started
Not one youād have called before the replay game Mac, thatās merely what Iām saying.
Then why not put that in your original post?
backtrack