Hurling Dream Team Ground Rules

Sport Hurling Dream Team
241

Has the Substitutes proposal been put to bed?
Soley in the interest of fairness for my competitors as Iā€™d be fairly certain Richie Power will have picked up an injury by now.

2 Likes
242

What a weekend of sport

3 Likes
243

@carryharry has a motion sent to the CCC requesting that the semi finals and finals be decided by committee.

I would be against it but I said I would let consensus dictate. I think he will struggle to get the 60% of the originally entered teams to agree

1 Like
244

I couldnā€™t give a fuck

245

Let the people have their say

1 Like
246

Against

247

And if you were to be part of the Comma-tea?

248

Against. Still

If you want an independent committee youd need to restart it

249

You may as well fold up the tent, this brings the whole thing into disrepute sure, changing the rules and format mid stream would be catastrophic to the integrity of the whole thing, which really would be a mighty shame at this stageā€¦

1 Like
250

Few lads canā€™t take a bateing

251

Itā€™s a real pity

252

Iā€™m sure Carryharry can explain his reasoning for wanting such a change and I am sure democracy will win out in the end. Whichever way that may be

253

There can be no possible valid reason for such a change midstream. An attempt at Gerrymandering perhaps?

254

Agreed, the bit of tribalism is the making of it anyhow.

255

Sure youā€™d only get a smaller dose of it with a committee and miss out on all the craic

256

Tis true, I 'd be all for an Up for the Match type thread before the final as well, cunts rolled out and bad songs to booth.

257

I believe we need a highly unbiased vote in seeing this inaugural Tournament out.

The only way I see it been a fair finish is if 2 Limerick posters make a final which canā€™t be taken as yet as a certainty.

I think itā€™s a very fair way to do this.

258

Sure you couldnā€™t guarantee no bias with a committee either. The nature of the forum is people have people they like or donā€™t like.

The fair way to do it would be to come up with a scoring system that didnā€™t involve voting.

For instance if a 12 point forward is marking a 4 point back, thatā€™s worth 8 points to the forward and so on. You could add in some nuance if you wanted to the scoring system.

Voting was always going to be hilarious though

259

Surely a novel Kilkenny/Tipp final would capture the imagination of the community.

1 Like
260

That is too complicated.

A S/F & Final judging panel.