He hadn’t a clue, but it was the right call inspite of himself
3 Likes
Stay classy Davy 
Davy the fat prick
Scandalous decision to give 65. Umpire hadn’t a scooby.
Déise were robbed.
Harsh on Waterford, can’t give that if your unsure
2 Likes
Questions
Was it a black card for the penalty when denying a clear goalscoring chance?
There was certainly another minute to play after the penalty and 65 delays
1 Like
Surely there was time for one puck out
Only if you are from Limerick.
Definitely time left. Between the penalty and the 65 they hardly played a minute
It was the correct decision though.
It was a 65
No way the umpire saw that.
There was at least a minute of play left.
1 Like
No. The penalty was for a push, which is not a black card offence.
2 Likes
It was but no way he saw it so he guessed. If it wasn’t a 65 that would have been some call… He hadn’t a clue
Hurling faces a bizarre problem in that the Munster hurling championship has become bigger than the All-Ireland. The All-Ireland quarter-finals on have been a serious let down the last couple of years and will be again this year.
2 Likes
No, wasn’t a cynical/deliberate foul. Was barely a foul at all I’d say.
Attitude brutal in the second half. David Fitz is in infuriating. As usual SOD and Duggan saved our skins.
Took a couple of replays to make out it was a 65, not sure how the umpire saw it
The agenda to keep Cork in the championship us clear as day
1 Like
There was 73:00 on the clock when the Clare keeper pucked the ball out and the free was given 4 or 5 seconds later. The free was taken about 45 seconds later which dropped down before going out for the 65. So there was about 10 seconds of play between 73:00 and the final whistle 2.5 minutes later.
2 Likes
He hadn’t a notion sure he half waved it wide before he said it was a 65.
The look of horror on his face 
Poor fucker. You couldn’t call it
1 Like
I think it was a foul, rather than a trip, deliberate pull down, or used his hurl in a careless manner, those are the only fouls that merit a black card. A foul, even if it denies a clear goal, isnt a black card unless they are fouled in one of the above 3 ways.
Agree, the decision and getting that 65 taken, took forever. The umpire went to wave it wide, then changed his mind. I dont know if it was the correct decision, but he hasnt a clue either if it was the correct decision or not. A game decided on that is fairly harsh. He might be accidentally correct though.