Why is it an either/or?
I think he’s done great work - particularly on the McCabe thing.
I think he does himself a disservice by the way he presents himself and would be taken far more seriously if he put in a bit of effort. Shatter would have walked the minute he had his Wallace Primeime interview if it was anyone else.
That being said, he’s no angel and hardly on a moral high ground. He knowingly defrauded the state of a substantial amount tax - just saying sorry and not paying it back doesn’t stack up in my book.