I find its tge old āprofessionsā that get most up in arms about new professions. Solicitors, Accountants and Physios the most.
Psychology is especially hard for them as they are the type of people who need it all in linear black and white fashion. Its hard to measure wirking with a SP, so they donāt understand it. Unless you win, then everythong works
What started out as an interview about her work as a sport psychologist with Paul OāConnell took a fairly bizarre turn when Caroline Currid brought Joe Brolly and suicide into it. Iād say Joe will come back with all guns blazing in an upcoming column.
As an aside, I think sheās the one whoās been picking the Dublin hurling team under Ger Cunningham. I could be wrong on this though.
I donāt think heās tweeted her directly but heās seething with these types and the GPA āusing mental health as a shield against any criticismā.
Is this lady for real itās as bad as that washing detergent survey a few weeks back that @treatystones gets a great giggle from ā¦ The fact this even got to print is an indictment of the state of the Irish press
No issue with challenging. If he was doing this on a personal basis. But he is consistently doing it through the medium of Twitter. Heās a busy barrister with loads of media and charity interests. Why does he take time out of his day to do this? If he really had an issue with these people why not take it up with them personally
Just because he might be right doesnāt mean itās not a form of bullying. I like Brolly but I think he is slightly unhinged is all. I think his behaviour is most unusual
I read the article with Currid before I saw the Brolly tweets and I must say I thought was a massive overreaction on his part. But he knows more about her than I do Iām sure
What specifically are you talking about? Youāre throwing out insults without any context.
Did you even read the interview which prompted Brollyās response tweet? Sheās conflating sport psychology with suicide prevention and using mental health as a weapon to hit back at Brollyās criticism of her industry.
Sheās essentially (and quite outrageously) calling him out for adding to the suicide problem so it doesnāt surprise me that heād respond to such rubbish in a caustic/sarcastic manner.
I donāt see how his tweet is scraping the barrel unless you think any mention of mental health (even when itās being used in a dubious manner for point scoring by Currid like in this instance) is removing the stigma and adding to the conversation. I think itās a fair bit more nuanced than that though and itās completely separate to whether any of his criticisms of sports psychology itself are valid or not or whether this lady is herself very good at it.