The Saturday/Sunday Game Thread

Is this the same McMahon that gouged the basketball player from Tyrone?

Months ago?

Weā€™re just saying that Pat Spillane isnā€™t a very balanced commentator.

I agree. And Iā€™m neither here nor there when it comes to Patā€¦ But rightly or wrongly he gave his view on the game he was analysing, maybe he went a tad over board by pulling up the rule in question, but it was a big talking point in that particular game and he gave his opinionā€¦ For fellow pundits to roll back and throw him under a bus to appease the Dubs is sickeningā€¦ You can pull up as many previous cases as you want, Connolly violently assaulted the linesman and spoke to him in a threatening mannerā€¦ It had to be talked about and it was. It also had to be punished, and it was. If you have a gripe, itā€™s with the law makers.

3 Likes

I love the way the two bullshit artists are trying to draw a parallel with any lad that ever gave an official a pat on the arm with what Dermo done :joy:
These boys are all about the letter of the law, priceless cunts

2 Likes

Violently assaulted. :rofl:

Rules are rules

An unholy alliance has formed here like the Torys and the DUP

As with everything else thereā€™s a place for common sense too, Iā€™ve no strong opinions on the Connolly incident but itā€™s idiotic to compare with some of what the bullshit twins have tried to.

Rules are rules.

Rules are to be interpreted in a common sense manner, no rule book is going to go into every possible scenario, only an idiot wouldnā€™t see the difference between Coopers and Connollys incidents.

Rules are rules

Rules are rules.

They are to applied under the directive they give and itā€™s pretty clear that laying your hand on a referee carries a 12 week ban.

Rules are to be interpreted in a common sense manner, no rule book is going to go into every possible scenario, only an idiot wouldnā€™t see the difference between Coopers and Connollys incidents

Rules are to be applied in the directive they give. The directive is very clear with regard to laying your hand on a match official, very clear, cut and dry.

One gave a match official a small shove.
The other puts his two hands on the referee.

Both offences carry a 12 week ban, the rule is very explicit on this.

You lack common sense, that doesnā€™t surprise me to be honest.

1 Like

Iā€™m not the one putting forward contradictory application of the rules.

Youā€™re the one who refuses to see that common sense trumps the strict letter of the law, Iā€™d say youā€™re the type of anal lad who waits for the green man :joy:

He is more of an orange man

I donā€™t have a problem with Connollys ban - it was deserved. However I donā€™t have much time for the ā€œpoor Spillaneā€ craic - he took glee in it from my watching of it at the time. He knows where he comes from too.

Itā€™s clear that the Sunday Game wields significant influence. It seems odd to me that the grassroot GAA fans are comfortable with a tv show often setting the agenda for their sport.

3 Likes