Unpopular opinions or views you hold

They are insufferable before and during a tournament. Even the most balanced of people.

3 Likes

Bizarrely the actual team seem likeable enough.
The majority of my ingerlish pals have little or no interest in the euros tbh.
Theyā€™re no more insufferable than the Limerick hurling mob.

Thereā€™s a couple in there that are alright. Mrs Moffat has done some long term research with both the menā€™s and womenā€™s sides which is really interesting. Sadly itā€™ll never be publicly published as itā€™ll be easy identify people i.e. Phil Neville

1 Like

:joy::joy::joy:

Id be interested in the research though if you have a pm.
Iā€™m fascinated by that sort of thing

Itā€™s tiresome in the early stages. Lads vociferously urging on Iran or Slovenia. Time enough in the quarters or semis. At least that Jude Bellingham goal saved us the drudgery of a Switzerland v Slovakia quarter-final.

1 Like

Iā€™m sorry youā€™re tired of it mate. I dont think Iā€™ll ever tire of watching england fail while thinking they have some right to win football tournaments.

4 Likes

Itā€™s better fun seeing them fail in the latter stages. Like when the Dublin footballers arenā€™t in the latter stages of championship and you donā€™t have anyone to strongly dislike then.

1 Like

Have you watched England play recently?

1 Like

Darragh Maloneyā€™s commentaries give GAA matches a ā€œbig match feelā€.

Not so much association football.

3 Likes

I agree with that, especially the football commentary part!

But at least in the GAA commentaries thereā€™s a bit of urgency in his delivery rather than twee ramblings.

I donā€™t think heā€™s a brill or gorgeous commentator by any stretch but heā€™s better than the other longstanding options.

6 Likes

A lot of this is about comparisons with the alternatives.

In association football the viewer compares Maloney to George Hamilton, and this comparison is a negative one for Maloney.

The comparisons in GAA are Ger Canning and Marty Morrissey.

Marty Morrissey does not have a big match voice. His voice will always be that of a commentator on Kilkenny v Antrim in the curtain raiser of a Ye Olde All-Ireland hurling semi-final double header, commentating as if heā€™s a concerned parent trying to encourage Antrim. ā€œOlcan McFettridge showing they love their hurling in the Glens of Antrim!ā€ ā€œOh look at that for skill by Aidan McCarry, they call him Beaver!ā€ ā€œCiaran Barr, oh look at that for strength! Oh he completely mishits it! What a shame for Antrim!ā€

Ger Canning has a better big match voice than Morrissey, but heā€™s Ger Canning.

Maloneyā€™s GAA commentaries are much more frantic than his association football commentaries and I think that frantic style suits him better. Also my primary memories of him doing GAA commentaries tend to be epic All-Ireland semi-finals, usually the football ones involving Dublin, in front of a full Croke Park. He did the Magic Mulligan goal too and the 2018 Cork v Limerick hurling semi-final.

15 Likes

Exactly. Marty is ideal for the camogie All Ireland final commentary for the same reasons you mention. Talking about incredible skills & unstoppable rockets as duffed shots dribble past a hapless keeper. Frantic is a good description of Maloneyā€™s GAA commentary style. You sense he doesnā€™t necessarily know the ins & outs of the game but it doesnā€™t matter versus the competition.

11 Likes

I like maloney . I think he does know the game . IIRC he played with Vincents in his youth

He was a Dublin minor footballer too

Was he ? Never knew and Vincents defo his club ?

Yeah around 89/90

1 Like

I stand corrected.

This is coming true. All the research has shown that the men would break through. I hope itā€™s fucking wrong

Maloney doesnā€™t really know hurling and the doubt comes out in his voice at times, heā€™ll say something and thereā€™ll be a quiet second as he waits to see does it pass muster.

But heā€™s good for football, heā€™s clearly a biased Dublin fan but thatā€™s no harm as it adds to his excitement. And is far better than Martys ā€œI just happened to be in the home village of named Clare panel member last week and they (who?) tell me heā€™s really up for this gameā€ shtick

1 Like