Was Michael Corleone right to have Fredo killed?

If you were in his position, would you have done the same?

Fredo was a liability. Great leaders make tough decisions. Fredo had to go.

Had to be done. Nothing personal, just business.

Fucking A right.

[LIST]
[]He regretted it for the rest of his life
[
]Was Fredo really that much of a liability by that time, was killing him really necessary?
[/LIST]

I didn’t care for The Godfather

He sided against the family, no brainer.

No.

Fredo wasnt a threat.

Whether or not Fredo was a threat was not relevant, he had to go. Fredo bit the hand that fed him when he made the deal with Roth and Johnny Ola. Michael would have been 100% to have killed him in Havana or even in the poolhouse when he returned to Tahoe, but mercifully didn’t out of love for his brother. He spares him for a time, allowing him to say goodbye to his mother and bond somewhat with his nephew. Ultimately though Michael’s ruthless business side wins the tug-of-war in his mind. Michael’s credibility would have been in tatters if he had spared his brother, no rival or associate would have taken him seriously as a leader. Much like when Tony Soprano had to order the hit on Vito Spatafore, or the Keyser Soze story about his family being held hostage in The Usual Suspects, a criminal leader must do what his rivals would not, do what is hardest and do what is most shocking. The Godfather II is about Michael’s transformation into a calculating, monstrous Mafia Don who puts business over all, and in the context of such, killing Fredo was the only option on the table.

Fucks sake. No point in me watching it now.

the Godfather movies are a load of shit

although the Modern Family take on it was brilliant

Great thread,I liked Fredo but he was a liability and as we saw was always a weak link in the family even as a child.Right choice!

You were always a liability in your family, pity no one popped you

Italians have no loyalty. Greasy, dago, wop, guinea bastards. They suck from the tit too long and have too many feminine traits as a result.

Italy is united and free. Oireland is not.

Fredo had to go, it was a signal to the world from Michael.

Michael did not regret it one bit.

I regret Godfather 3 was made however.

What’s that got to do with american war hero Michael Corleone?

+1. Filthy fuckers who stay at home riding their mothers until they find some poor girl who will marry them who they will then beat up and cheat on for the rest of their lives. A diseased society.

had to go, he was a little rat

What about San Marino and the Vatican?