Itās a very fair comparison in one way in that itās somebody who hasnāt been involved at all in that year being parachuted in. For example, had, hypothetically, Gavin OāMahony come into the Limerick squad before the hurling final it would have been pretty much an identical scenario to OāNeill returning in 2008, ie. a player who has a close relationship with the squad having been a stalwart member of it until a short time before, yet I highly doubt him being parachuted in would have gone down too well.
However, McKenna is a different scenario again in another way in that he is basically a stranger to the team. The most comparable case to this rumoured one is Tadhg Kennelly in 2002. If I remember rightly, he togged out and was in the matchday squad for the final against Armagh, but never came on. But even in that case, Iām pretty sure heād played in an All-Ireland under-21 semi-final two weeks before that.
Paidi OāSe got a lot of criticism in Kerry for not bringing him on. Personally, I wouldnāt have had him near the squad in the first place.
Kenneally was training with them in the lead up to final, in the end Paidi didnāt tog him the day of the final despite the speculation and temptation