[QUOTE=“caoimhaoin, post: 949049, member: 273”]You are going down to club league game now.
How the fuck would you know weather O Neill or Hurley was at Minor. You maybe, at a stretch saw one game Hurley played, the final.
Anyway minor is not a barometer most GAA people use for senior players.
And your comments on Colm O Neill are laughable. Every time he stays injury free he becomes unmarkable. He had already shown this year in a limited time on the field that he has it all. Anyone with a football brain in their head would have him in top 5 forwards in the game, many would have him top 3.
Your argument is based on he is from Cork an I am from Cork this you feel the need to try and demote him in someway, as if it matters. The fact is I would give the Tyrone lads plenty credit when they perform on big days in CP. I actually do have high respect for them, I think they get an incredible amount out of themselves. And as it happens I don’t believe, at least till this year, Cork haven’t made the most of their talent.
However Tyrone are still hugely reliant on an aging group if soldiers like Cavanagh and the McMahons. They can’t stay going for 70 mins in CP and that was crudely exposed last year by mayo. Tyrone have produced good lively forwards from recent underage teams but are running out of the central dominat big men you need to win.
If you were involved in football you’d know that same thing drips down to every level, club Junior even. A few big men, scoring forwards and 6-8 very fit runners who preferably are good ball carriers and kick passers. The last 2 and the amount of scoring forwards are generally what determines what your level is. But big mobile men are a must.[/QUOTE]
Of the team that started yesterday against Down, only Sean Cavanagh was over 30.
Morgan 23
McCrory 26
Justy 28
McNamee 23
McNabb 24
Donnelly 24
Harte 24
C. Cavanagh 26
Clarke 22
Emmet McKenna 25
S. Cavanagh 31
McGinley 25
McCurry 21
Ronan O’Neill 22
Coney 24
Justin McMahon is no veteran, Sean Cavanagh and Joe McMahon are the only players 30 or over who I would expect to be regulars in the starting team this year and both still have a lot to offer. I’d expect O’Neill, Gormley and Penrose to be used as impact subs this year as they have been used in the last two games and there are few better players to come in and steady the ship. Your comments are respecting Tyrone are ridiculous as you have done nothing but discredit and write them off for the past 18 months.
Ronan O’Neill was the top scorer in the 2010 Minor Championship, I think his form over all grades in the past 3/4 months at club/county/college show that he showing signs of fulfilling his potential as a top minor into a top player. You describing him as an average county forward just shows what an utter botton you are and how insincere your “respect” for Tyrone is. I doubt there is a forward in the country the same age as McCurry (maybe McBrearty) who has scored as much and yet you refuse to give him any sort of praise. I don’t expect Cavanagh and McMahon to be asked to carry out the same role as last year, Cavanagh has already been moved into the half forward line and I’d be hoping Joe McMahon will in a holding position at no.6 or in midfield much like how Harte deployed Collie Holmes. We also have Niall Morgan this year who missed the whole of last season.
As for Colm O’Neill, my comments are fair on not based on prejudice, I have given him credit in that he is an excellent finisher but I think he can be sussed out by a sticky man marker. I’d rate Hurley ahead of him as he is much more capable of winning his own ball.