The stats are just another string to his bow…
Anyway reid is way better than Callanan. Reid v Canning would have been the real debate but that would stick in the munster craw
Callanan, Hoggie, Joe, Reid - in that order.
1 Like
Adrian Fenlon v Tommy Dunne would have been a much better debate
4 Likes
That would be the order munster simpletons would put them in, yes.
Ever strike you that when a munster team wins an all ireland theyve ‘reinvented’ hurling. When a leinster or connacht team do theres no such bluster.
TJ>Both, next.
the last Leinster team to win it outside of Kilkenny was Offaly in 1998. So yeah, when Kilkenny win it there’s no bluster.
Connacht… haha.
Since Offaly won it, Cork, Tipp, Limerick and Clare have all reinvented hurling
Agreed
Thats what was claimed alright
Standard Maroon - everyone that disagrees is a simpleton.
Callanan cemented his place as one of the all time greats last year- up there with Ring, Mackey, Rackard- and is the best player of the last 10 years hand down. Joe could only dream of having a year like Seamus had last year. Year after year Callanan has improved - Joe has been up and down, fighting managers, dictating tactics and looking for large sums of money to open new pitches. Seamus has done his talking on the field.
Miles better than Callanan.
Tough debate with joe. Just on a while career id give it to joe as he hadn’t the help tj did.
Did you ever hold a hurl. Serious question? Elverys doesn’t count.
how about Liam Watson vs Shane Brick
it’s impossible get a reasoned debate when muldoons are comparing players within their own county
Once, to beat away a few nettles when looking for a soccer ball.
6 Likes
Tough call. Joes superior levels of personal hygiene will probably swing it
Id believe you seeing hurls before id believe you seeing nettles
do nettles only grow out the country?
Real nettles do. Not soft townie nettles reared on monster munch and wham bars.
yeah, nettles reared on farmers disappointment and cow shit would be much harder alright