The point is that thereās a difference between soldiering and concentration camps. That really shouldnāt have to be spelled out in fairness.
I personally canāt see the difference between the guard on the watch tower, the guy delivering the gas canisters and the pilot dropping bombs on Greater Manchester.
or the pilot dropping bombs on Dresden
2 Likes
There are degrees of wrong. Factories to round up and exterminate people en mass based on race is at the apex. It is completely different to a soldier prosecuting war. The reason they are going after such low level people is that it is considered that the activities there were so morally repugnant that anyone that knew of what was going on there, and still participated, at whatever level, is guilty of a crime.
Itās difficult to imagine what I might have done if I was in the camp guards position but I tend to agree with you.
Thatās exactly it. You may have been killed for refusing to participate, but even at that any knowledge and participation in an enterprise so evil is considered a crime. Thatās the reasoning behind it and Iād tend to agree with it.
She was an 18 year old typist. I doubt she had much say in what she could refuse to do in the Third Reich.
Itās prosecuting people for not being brave enough to be shot in the head.
10 Likes
Whatās the thoughts on dropping atomic bombs on 2 cities āpour encourager les autresā?
1 Like
I also think people are forgetting that a similar fate may have been visited upon their families.
Iād like to think Iād have refused, and taken a bullet, but plenty of decent people have been brainwashed by PR and fear and patriotism, and we are all, thankfully, armchair pundits. Siege mentality does strange things to people, never mind indoctrination from birth.
Plenty of otherwise Iām sure perfectly decent people facilitated the Magdalene laundries.
2 Likes
Disproportionate, unjustifiable, abhorrent.
1 Like
I often wonder could they not have dropped it somewhere in the Japanese countryside first, and said the next one is on your head?
I remember picking up the sheets my mother left in for cleaning from the Good Shepherd
3 Likes
How many typists were killed/imprisoned over that?
The Japanese started it and then brought a knife to a nuclear war. They never apologized for their war crimes either.
1 Like
I remember the disquiet at the walls. I didnāt understand what it was about, but definitely had the feeling of stigma about one such establishment. We were only kids. Your ma will have thought it an act of charity, as who could believe the church could be bad ?
None that Iām aware of. Thatās not really relevant to anything though. And even then, it wasnāt as bad as genocide.
What are your thoughts on the tattooist of Auschwitz?
Iāve often thought this a quandary.
I doubt he was overly popular amongst the poor souls he was branding.
No many countries donāt tend to apologise for their war crimes while they might still be held to account for them.
Iāve not read it and donāt know anything about it Iām afraid.
As regards disproportionate, whilst I wholeheartedly agree, many serious historians think the atomic bombs resulted in less loss of life than had the war dragged on.
Perhaps itās best not to send other peopleās children to attack another nation.