Galway v Tipperary - All Ireland Senior Hurling Semi-Final 2017

I’m torn on who I want to win this one.

I generally support Galway against Tipperary given that I have more connections to Galway, such as living here and coming here every Christmas and summer since I was born, but the majority of the Galway posters on here are absolute neanderthals (if you’re a Galway poster and believe you’re the target of this jibe you probably are, if you’re a Galway poster but believe you aren’t the target of this jibe you probably aren’t) whereas the Tipp lads are generally pretty sound. And my grandfather who I never met was from Cahir.

Tough one.

I’ll probably say Galway, but all the same it’ll be terribly funny if they lose.

4 Likes

Ye remind me of a team i know :thinking:

I still can’t call it but I’m starting to edge towards Tipperary.

:clap::clap::clap::clap::clap:

The way it should be.

Phew, thanks Sid.

You think tipp

Tentatively, Joe.

I am going the other way but sticking with tip

Mickey Cahill has never been scared of anyone in his life mate

Galway going to win this one. Mightn’t be by too much but they’ll win it.

1 Like

@TreatyStones How do you see this one going?

Bill Cooper has pretty much spent the whole summer picking up the oppositions centre forward when he has drifted allowing Mark Ellis sit and hold the middle of the Cork defence. Yet I doubt would accuse Cork of playing a sweeper.

Given how fit players are, the emphasis to carry the ball into contact and how teams commit men between the 40s there is normally very little space and out and out man marking between midfielders doesn’t really occur. Just because a back holds his position when his man moves out the field that doesn’t make him a sweeper. Kilkenny’s dominance at half back was driven by their three half backs staying in situ and a massive work rate from their half forwards close space and pick up/close down any free men or forwards forwards drifting out the field.

6 Likes

Could be a while before @TreatyStones replies. He’s on his way to IKEA and he’s heading for a faerie stone in a field outside Kilconnell after that.

5 Likes

He’s a wise man.

Stop talking sense Puke, a few lads can’t see these simple things in front of them.

You mean to say the whole time kilkenny were saying they don’t do tactics they were actually playing sweepers? :eek:

He is far more of a ‘spoiler’ thsn TDB and nothing like as good a distributor or hurler so isnt half as obvious. But you’re right he is essentially a sweeper but of midfield area more than anything. Hes been used v well really and role really suits him

Ellis would be the sweeper in that scenario mate, not Cooper

1 Like

What have we to be confident about Joe? We havent won one since 88, not even a soft one.

1 Like

+1. Poor @gilgamboa was all over the place there.

2 Likes