Galway v Tipperary - All Ireland Senior Hurling Semi-Final 2017

There was two competitions. You had to win the first one to win the second one

So all teams had to play two games to win the All Ireland competition? Thank you.

God be with the days in the 80s 90s when every GAA team ended up in Gran Canaria in January .

1 Like

Sigh, do we have to go over this again this year. Yes it was soft. They beat a young and callow Tipperary team who had played 5 matches to win Munster and were still drunk from ending the famine. Even then they needed the assistance of the referee the pivotal moment being the disallowing of a Nicholas English point that would have given Tipperary the lead, Galway got a goal from the resultant free. The referee on that occasion? Ballyskenagh man (Everyone in Ballyskenagh hates Tipp) Gerry Kirwan who also went on to ride Tipperary in the 1988 decider, of course 2009 proved there was never a truer saying as “black cat, black kitten”. In the final they beat probably the worst KK team in 40 years on an aul wet day. KK were in the middle of a run that would see no all ireland for 9 years.
1987 = soft All Ireland qed.

3 Likes

Incorrect again, Munster and Leinster teams had to win 4/5 games to win the All Ireland competition. They literally could not win the All Ireland competition without winning 4/5 games

Jesus. I remember Limerick winning that “warm up provincial tournament” a few years ago. I think it’s called the Munster FInal? Anyway, the cunts went mad. About 20,000 of them on the field a hoopin and a hollerin. They must be fair success starved to be getting so excited about a warm up competition.

1 Like

The All Ireland competition consisted of 2 games did it not? Therefore it is a fact that to win the All Ireland competition you needed to win two games - previous competitions have no impact on this statement.

1 Like

Yes- It’s a separate competition and has it’s own merits and bragging rights. What’s the issue here?

Yes the All Ireland competition consisted of two games. That doesn’t have any relevance to the correct point that Munster and Leinster teams had to win 4/5 games to win the All Ireland competition

If the All Ireland competition consisted of 2 games, which you have just said it did, then you only needed to win 2 games to win it, mate - you’re being very stupid now.

Fairer? What was fair about beaten teams still in the competition?

It doesn’t consist of 2 games, it never did, unless you were from Galway mate.

1 Like

Munster and Leinster teams had to qualify for the All Ireland series by winning 2/3 games beforehand. Show me a scenario where a Munster or Leinster team won 2 games to win an All Ireland?

It’s been established that provincial and All Ireland are two separate competitions bud…

Now choco behave yourself. You are taking advantage of those poor innocent fools.

You just said the All Ireland competition consisted of two games, did you not? Now you’re talking about qualifying competitions - The All Ireland competition consisted of 2 games - Galway were no different to anyone else in the All Ireland competition.

Actually in 1980 , Limerick only needed to.win one game and we still couldn’t manage it. There was a few years there where the winners of the provincial qualified automatically for the AIF. I don’t know bit I’m betting that @GeoffreyBoycott could probably tell me when the ulster champions entered / reenter ed the AI series

Give it a rest you tiresome bore.

11 Likes

@ChocolateMice is running amok here :clap:

1 Like

Incorrect. Galway didn’t have to qualify. The other teams did, by winning their province. Thus, those teams had to win 4/5 games to win the All Ireland while Galway didn’t