Ah come on Gman, Donaghy is a joke selection, even within his own team Geaney had a much better season. Not to mention a few others. McHugh not getting one for Donegal is shameful.
It’s farcical though, and we shouldn’t even discuss it they get it so wrong.
The hurling is similar, Brendan Maher and Paul Murphy got awards for playing well other years, Shane McGrath is more than a bit debate able.
[QUOTE=“caoimhaoin, post: 1036039, member: 273”]Ah come on Gman, Donaghy is a joke selection, even within his own team Geaney had a much better season. Not to mention a few others. McHugh not getting one for Donegal is shameful.
It’s farcical though, and we shouldn’t even discuss it they get it so wrong.
The hurling is similar, Brendan Maher and Paul Murphy got awards for playing well other years, Shane McGrath is more than a bit debate able.[/QUOTE]
There was fuck all unexpected with them, hence why no one was mugged off. Doesn’t mean I’d agree with how the selections have gone, just that it was no surprise in both selections. It was easy enough to predict 29 of 34 awards given. So no one was mugged off.
The selection process and criteria in winning one is a different discussion
[QUOTE=“Gman, post: 1036041, member: 112”]There was fuck all unexpected with them, hence why no one was mugged off. Doesn’t mean I’d agree with how the selections have gone, just that it was no surprise in both selections. It was easy enough to predict 29 of 34 awards given. So no one was mugged off.
The selection process and criteria in winning one is a different discussion[/QUOTE]
McHugh was completely mugged off, as was Chin.