The Anti Rugby Football Thread Pt 2

Iā€™m a rugby fan but one aspect of the Netflix doc which rankled was the use of the term ā€œWorld Classā€. I think it was the Welsh who were wary of the potentially world class Irish team. Well when thereā€™s only about 4 serious rugby outfits at present then itā€™s easy enough be categorised as world class. Pundits and players alike seem to focus on physicality rather than structures and variation of play when discussing the strongest teams.

I suppose the limited pool of teams in rugby bears striking resemblances to hurling.

Graham Geraghty was setting records in bleep tests at Arsenal 30 years ago. The Tuilagiā€™s nephew who plays for France is 24 stone at just 19 years of age. Heā€™d hardly be serviceable at Junior B level in Gaelic football.

Edit: You had the same story on Geraghty before me.

2 Likes

Lolz

Obviously thats not true and the oirish always gassed out vs the aussies

How can an amateur be as a fit as a professional

Iirc, the greatest gga team of all time got fit by doing laps in kinsealy

https://twitter.com/CraicOfTheAsh/status/1757357640424837142

Former pro rugby player Donners reckons intercounty hurling requires far more committment than Rugby. Thats good enough for me.

1 Like

Isnt the story that paul merson put it in his autobiography, like of everything he did in his.life, a lad being fit in training supersedes a lot of it and gets a page

Because they are amateur and have to overcompensate

We beat them out the gate in 2004 anyway. My first time attending a game in Croker. The day the little Jack Russell invaded the pitch.

How many times have you told us that intercounty is ruined because itā€™s professional in everything but name?

1 Like

But they still work which means they donā€™t have time for proper recovery which leads
To situations we see regularly in the round robins and in last years football championships. Where one team is completely out on its feet.

1 Like

So amateur then, and not professional in everything but name? Iā€™m glad we wonā€™t be hearing you go with that line again so.

1 Like

Are you just stupid or what?

Yes the gaa season is professional in all but name. They have made money a huge factor in teams abilities to compete. Ie professionalism. That has absolutely nothing to do with a players fitness. Hurlers donā€™t need to be nearly as fit as soccer players because they donā€™t run nearly as much. It isnā€™t hard but maybe itā€™s hard
For you to understand.

Iā€™ve rinsed you in horse racing, rinsed you in soccer, rinsed you in rugby and Iā€™ll do the same in gaa too.

Youā€™re best of moving on before making a show out of yourself yet again.

Professional soccer players are a million miles ahead of GAA Players athletically.

Lads like Phil Foden barely touch the ground when they move.

They are complete freaks.

3 Likes

I donā€™t think you know the difference between professionalism and commercialism, or fantasy and reality. Professional in everything but name and fitness levels can be your new line sure.

Bring back Sports Stars.

Thereā€™s surely a gap in the market for celebrity sports people to go up against each other to find out whoā€™s the fittest.

2 Likes

Destroyed yet again. You know nothing about anything.

Iā€™d say there would be a bit of a gap between Phil Foden and some journeyman at Drogheda United too though.

1 Like

Indeed.

Top professional soccer players are a million miles ahead of top GAA players.

A top GAA player vs LOI player would be a closer contest.

Back in the 00s they did a comparison and LOI players weee way fitter

The gap has.grown since as more teams are full time

Remember the late and great Jerry Kieran destroying Colm Parkinson over this topic on Newstalk.

1 Like