Tipperary Matters

Billionaire thoroughbred stud owner John Magnier and two of his children are involved in a legal dispute relating to the proposed purchase of a 751-acre farm estate and mansion in the Golden Vale.

The property, Barne Estate, was last month reported to have been bought by Magnierā€™s Coolmore Stud operation.

The property, Barne Estate, was last month reported to have been bought by Magnierā€™s Coolmore Stud operation.

Barne Estate had been on the market since July, with a guide price of ā‚¬13.5m.

But a deal for the period house and farm near Clonmel, Co Tipperary appears to have hit a significant snag, with parties involved now heading to the High Court.

Mr Magnier, his son John Paul and daughter Katherine Wachman initiated proceedings on Monday against the estateā€™s manager, Richard Thomson-Moore, Barne Estate Limited and two companies registered in Jersey.

The Magniers are being represented in the matter by ā€˜Big Fiveā€™ law firm Arthur Cox.

It is thought Coolmore believed it had a deal for the property. However, it remains advertised as being ā€˜for saleā€™ by selling agents Savills and REA Stokes & Quirke.

While full details of the dispute have not been publicly disclosed, High Court records show the Magniers are suing for the ā€œspecific performanceā€ of an agreement.

Barne Estate in the Golden Vale. Photo: MyHome

This is a relief usually sought to force another party to a contract to comply with their obligations under that contract.

A spokesman for Coolmore said he could not comment as the matter was before the courts.

Attempts to make contact with a representative of Barne Estate proved unsuccessful.

The property has been in the hands of the Moore family since 1654.

It comprises a large farm and a 17th century 12-bedroom chateau-style mansion overlooking a lake.

About 631 of the Barne Estateā€™s 751 acres is classified as first-class fertile and versatile tillage land, according to the selling agents.

The mansion itself is valued at ā‚¬2.5m, measures over 1,500sqm in size across four floors, and is reached via a tree-lined driveway.

It is surrounded by formal gardens, a walled garden, and a tennis court.

The property is located not far from Coolmoreā€™s headquarters in Fethard.

Coolmore has been buying up land that has become available in the area in recent years.Previous purchases include a 600-acre tillage farm in Grange, reportedly bought for ā‚¬11m in 2013, and a 360-acre parcel of land in Marlfield, said to have cost around ā‚¬6m.

Those lands have been used for tillage farming since being purchased.

Mr Magnier is considered one of the most influential figures in the world of horseracing and breeding.

His Coolmore operation spans several locations in Ireland, the United States and Australia.

The billionaire once had a stake of close to 29pc in Manchester United, which he sold to the Glazer family in 2005.

The football clubā€™s former manager Sir Alex Ferguson was involved in a high-profile legal dispute with Mr Magnier over ownership of lucrative stallion Rock of Gibraltar. The matter was settled in 2004.

Greed is an awful thing

6 Likes

They buy the land which once had hundreds of animals and were central to the local economy then replace it with big fields of tillage.

Itā€™s cut and resown once a year.

They are killing Tipperary agriculture.

Itā€™s only a matter of time before the IFA call for something to be done to stop Maude II.

Did a right dirty one on the community in Dualla too.

1 Like

Ten years ago Har. You could have stopped this :man_shrugging:t2:

Tbf, a fair few of the land deals done in past the farmers went directly to Coolmore as opposed to going to Auctioneers.

A few tbf have ignored all advances and took smaller fees to keep it in local famers hands. Not too many now, but a few have.

The great Spud lining out there I see.

4 Likes

Whatā€™s his play here. Surely easier ways for him to make money at this stage than tillage farming?

Or has he figured out the farmers secret that they are only pretending to be poor?

Area aid payments are hugeā€¦.

Some serious titans of Tipperary Agriculture on show there.

Whatā€™s 10,000 acres of land when you can have 20,000 acres of land.

A local farmer near us was coming to the end of his life and sold directly to the neighbours. Coolmore took legal proceedings on it but were beaten for once.

4 Likes

That Barne deal could get very messy

It will.

Coolmore have already ruined Fethard as a football powerhouse. They now want to ruin Tipperary as a whole.

Nobody gives a flying crap about their 1000 grade ones.

They paid silly money for Barne, itā€™s middling tillage ground at best

The story goes that not so long ago, Aidan went into some farmers place down in Faugheen or somewhere and wrote out on a cheque what heā€™d pay for the farm.

The farmer said to treble it, and weā€™ve a deal, to which Aidan duly obliged.

I know Ana Oā€™Brien is running a big stud farm just past the new Hurling field in Carrick but think this is another place.

Before they only purchased the very best, now itā€™s anything half middling, before long, theyā€™ll be buying 80 acres in Kilcommon.

1 Like

Spot onā€¦

Anything actually goes now.

1 Like

Mother or daughter? Joesphā€™s place or another yard?